As we now enter the time of year where many people in the UK are preparing to indulge in feasting and partying, what better way to mark this festive season than to explore how food and drink have been enjoyed and represented throughout history and across the globe. Thankfully, the Art Library and Bodleian collections contain a wide range of books on the subject – hopefully with something to tempt any palate!
Image of the display for The Art and archaeology of Eating Drinking and Being Merry
Food is deeply embedded in many cultures around the world and the way that artists depict their national cuisines has a lot to say about not only diets, but also politics and the way that these artists want their culture and its food to be seen. For example, the book Farm to Table: Art, Food, and Identity in the Age of Impressionism explores how attitudes to food – long a source of French soft power – were shaped by the turbulent period at the end of the nineteenth-century, and how impressionist painters sought to both stabilise and question pre-existing ideals. Then, in Art and Appetite: American Painting, Culture, and Cuisine, each essay by the book’s various authors explores a different period of US painting, and how depictions of food also represented trends of anxiety, nationalism, and consumerism.
Left: The cover for the book Farm to Table; Right: Book cover for Art and Appetite
The way that food loaded with meaning can be used to tell national and cultural stories can also be seen in ancient literature. As John Wilkins argues in The Boastful Chef: The Discourse of Food in Ancient Greek Comedy, for Greek poetry and drama, the consumption of food, is usually associated with successful sacrifices to the gods, and therefore, a world running as it should. Because these sacrifices are so often unsuccessful in tragedy and epic, it is only comedy that is allowed to return to the subject of food repeatedly. Wilkins furthermore notes that comedy, above all other Greek genres available to us, includes enough variety of people and life experiences that the authors are able to explore the cultural significance of food in a wide-ranging way. Similarly, in Fillets of Fatling and Goblets of Gold, Dan Belnap examines Ugaritic literature to find evidence of the ritual significance of feasts and other meals in the Ancient Near East.
However, visual art and literary depictions can only tell half the story. To learn more, it really helps to examine archaeology and material culture, and this is part of what I have found so fascinating about exploring this topic at the Art Library: food and drink is a great medium for exploring the intersection between art and archaeology and for showing just how much they’re linked! It can be difficult, though, to find direct evidence of food and its consumption, due to the biodegradable nature of foodstuffs – outside of famous outliers like the carbonised bread uncovered in Pompeii (pictured below). Even though, as shown in the book Ancient Starch Research, there are methods available to archaeologists for looking at ancient food directly, these are very specific and reliant on chance.
Left: Carbonised bread excavated from Pompeii. Source: Wikimedia Commons; Right: The Book Cover for Ancient Starch Research
The information from such methods can be supplemented by looking at the tools that people used to prepare and eat their food. For instance, in Dining with the Sultan, Jessica Hallett details how Persian turquoise jars found as far afield as Japan and Chinese tableware found at Iranian sites from the same period attest to the connectedness of the Abbasid world. It was this connectedness that allowed the Abbasid empire access to commodities such as cinnamon and rhubarb. Then, in Elegant Eating: Four Hundred Years of Dining in Style and Feeding Desire: Design and the Tools of the Table, 1500-2005, there are many examples of more modern, but no less fascinating historical utensils. Have you ever heard of a macaroni knife? What about an ice cream hatchet? I certainly hadn’t before this book.
Left: Book cover for Dining With the Sultan; Right: Cover for Feeding Desire.
Then again, the beautiful designs of the cutlery and ceramics in the last two books show how it’s not always easy to draw a line between visual and material culture. For example, the exhibition recorded in Feast & Fast: The Art of Food in Europe 1500-1800 relies on a mixture of both objects and artworks, and sometimes a blending of the two, as utensils for serving consumables, are often adorned with images of them too, such as the pineapple-inspired Staffordshire porcelain teapot shown below. A very similar Staffordshire teapot is also featured in Feast & Fast.
A Staffordshire porcelain teapot decorated with a pineapple inspired design with spiked leaves from the base, and a yellow textured design over the rest of the main body. Source: Wikimedia Commons
However, Feast: Radical Hospitality in Contemporary Art goes a step further than this and asks what if the act of eating and serving food can be art. These range from Tom Marioni’s The Act of Drinking Beer With Friends is the Highest Form of Art to Marina Abramović’s Communist Body/Fascist Body.
I was particularly inspired by Los Angeles-based art collective Fallen Fruit, and I especially enjoyed reading about their Public Fruit Jam projects. During these events, members of the public are invited to bring fruit and to work with strangers to make jam. I love this concept because of the way it encourages community collaboration and new approaches to cooking and ingredients.
People taking part in one of Fallen Fruit’s Public Fruit Jam events. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
On that note, we hope that you too find something that inspires you in this collection of books – or perhaps just something new. From all of us at the Art Library, have a satisfying and fun-filled holiday season!
Bibliography
P. Arbiter, Petronii Arbitri Cena Trimalchionis, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1975.
V. Avery and M. Calaresu (eds.), Feast & Fast: The Art of Food in Europe 1500-1800, London : Philip Wilson Publishers, Bloomsbury Publishing Plc, 2019.
J. A. Barter (ed.), Art and Appetite: American Painting, Culture, and Cuisine, Chicago, The Art Institute of Chicago, 2013.
H. Barton and R. Torrence, Ancient Starch Research, Walnut Creek CA, Left Coast Press, 2006.
D. Belnap, Fillets of Fatling and Goblets of Gold: The Use of Meal Events in the Ritual Imagery in the Ugaritic Mythological and Epic Texts, Piscataway NJ, Gorgias Press, 2008.
K. Bendiner, Food in Painting: From the Renaissance to the Present, London, Reaktion, 2004.
A. Briers, Eat, Drink and Be Merry, Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, 1990.
S. Coffin, Feeding Desire: Design and the Tools of the Table, 1500-2005, New York, Assouline, 2006.
G. E. Cummins, Antique Boxes – Inside and Out: For Eating, Drinking and Being Merry, Work, Play and the Boudoir, Easthampton MA, Antique Collectors’ Club, 2006.
A. Dalby, Food in the Ancient World from A-Z, London, Routledge, 2003.
A. Dalby, Siren Feasts: A History of Food and Gastronomy in Greece, London, Routledge, 1996.
J. Davidson, Courtesans and Fishcakes: The Consuming Passions of Classical Athens, London, HarperCollins, 1997.
L. DeWitt and A. J. Eschelbacher (eds.), Farm to Table: Art, Food, and Identity in the Age of Impressionism, New Haven, Yale University Press, 2024.
P. Glanville and H. Young (eds.), Elegant Eating: Four Hundred Years of Dining in Style, London, V&A Publications, 2002.
K. J. Gremillion, Ancestral Appetites: Food in Prehistory, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2011.
J. Hallett, ‘Abbasid Tableware and Changing Food Culture’ in L. Komaroff (ed.), Dining with the Sultan: The Fine Art of Feasting, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County Museum of Art, 2023, pp.41-45.
S. Hill and J. M. Wilkins, Food in the Ancient World, Malden MA., Blackwell Publishing, 2006.
P. S. Kindstedt, Cheese and Culture: A History of Cheese and its Place in Western Civilization, White River Junction VT., Chelsea Green Publishing, 2012.
L. Komaroff (ed.), Dining with the Sultan: The Fine Art of Feasting, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County Museum of Art, 2023.
F. Lissarrague, The Aesthetics of the Greek Banquet: Images of Wine and Ritual (Un Flot D’Images), trans. A. Szegedy-Maszak, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1990.
P. E. McGovern, Uncorking the Past: The Quest for Wine, Beer, and Other Alcoholic Beverages, Berkeley CA, University of California Press, 2009.
D. Newman, ‘Gourmet Pleasures: Gastronomic Culture in Islamic Lands in the Middle Ages’, in L. Komaroff (ed.), Dining with the Sultan: The Fine Art of Feasting, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County Museum of Art, 2023, pp. 21-25.
H. S. Nielsen and I. Nielsen (eds.), Meals in a Social Context: Aspects of the Communal Meal in the Hellenistic and Roman World, Aarhus, Aarhus University Press, 1998.
K. O’Connor, The Never-Ending Feast: The Anthropology and Archaeology of Feasting, London, Bloomsbury Academic, 2015.
J. Paul, Food Provisions for Ancient Rome: A Supply Chain Approach, London, Routledge, 2021.
G. Riley, Food in Art: From Prehistory to the Renaissance, London, Reaktion Books, 2014.
S. Smith (ed.), Feast: Radical Hospitality in Contemporary Art, Chicago, Smart Museum of Art, 2013.
U. Söderlind, Ancient Foodways: Gastronomy in Egypt, Greece, Rome, Luristan and the Muslim World, Malmö : Universus Academic Press, 2015.
W. J. Strachan, ‘French Bibliophile Society Banquet Menus: Avati, Picasso, Aïzpiri, Minaux, and Jobert’, Private Library, Quarterly Journal of the Private Libraries Association, 4th series, vol. 4, no. 3, Autumn 1991, pp. 81-99.
D. L. Thurmond, A Handbook of Food Processing in Classical Rome: For Her Bounty No Winter, Leiden, Brill, 2006.
F. Whitlum-Cooper, Discover Liotard & the Lavergne Family Breakfast, London, National Gallery Global, 2023.
Plants, planet and the picturesque in the Art Library
By Olly Marshall
To celebrate Green Libraries week (27th October- 2nd November), we at the Art, Archaeology and Ancient World Library wanted to draw attention to some items in our collection that reflect on ecology, climate, and the human relationship with nature. In our collections, we have resources that look back on the human-planetary relationship thousands of years ago, and books that look to the future of the planet and how we may have to adapt to and process the changes to our planet amidst a climate crisis and mass extinction event.
Man in Nature: Historical Perspectives on Man in His Environment and Understanding Imperiled Earth: How Archaeology and Human History Inform a Sustainable Future both posit that the way humans in the past have treated, learnt from, cared for and used their environment can inform how we ensure our own future. In particular I recommend the fourth essay in Man in nature, which discusses how the ancient Greeks had their culture, economy and mythology shaped by their knowledge and mastery of the ocean- demonstrated in Homer’s Catalogue of Ships, the Greco-Persian war and marine motifs in Aegean art.
To learn about the relationships Ancient Egyptians had with nature, The Ancient Egyptians and the Natural World: Flora, Fauna, & Science and Egyptian Bioarchaeology: Humans, Animals, and the Environment eachaddress the intersection of science and archaeology and examine how biological and cultural understanding are needed for looking at human, animal and botanical remains. Among plenty of chapters on mummified animals (between the two books mummified crocodiles, fish, dogs and cats get a look in), there is also reflection on how dental records, faunal remains and carbon-14 dating can help inform us how ancient Egyptians engaged with their natural environment. Most interesting to me was a chapter in Egyptian bioarchaeology on dendroarchaeology, in which the growth rings of trees are studied in archaeological wood to reveal environmental and behavioural information.
European archaeology more your bag? We’ve got some great resources from our lower ground floor collections. Plants and people: choices and diversity through time takes an interdisciplinary look at agriculture and botany, mainly in the western Old World. As well as domesticated food crops this textbook explores wild food plants, medicinal and ritual plants, and how plants have been connected to social status and identity.
Furthermore, European prehistory gives us a compelling example of how humans have navigated climate change and rising sea levels in the past, through the story of Doggerland. This now-submerged landmass once connected the British Isles to mainland Europe but was also so much more than that. It was home to many – attested to by the fact that stone houses have been found there, and by the wealth of artefacts that have washed up dated from that period. These include adorable amber animal statues like this bear from the coast of Fanø, Denmark.
Image of a model of a bear made of amber (Wikipedia Commons).
In Europe’s lost world: the rediscovery of Doggerland and Mapping Doggerland: the Mesolithic landscapes of the southern North Sea you can read about the finds that have been discovered and the theory of how they were found, retrieved, and identified.
Professor Geoffrey W Dimbleby puts it best in Ecology and archaeology– “Ecology forms the meeting point for the study of the past environments and those aspects of man’s culture and behaviour which are related to his environment. No longer is it possible to study one without the other; what we have to analyse is a system in which man himself is, and has been for a long time, an ecological factor as well as a member of the ecological community.”
As well as looking at the material factors of our relationship with nature, it’s also important to reflect on how our environment is represented in our art and literature. Through ecocriticism- the analysis of how the natural world is portrayed in artistic and cultural output- we learn about how the perceptions of nature and our place in it have changed.
In the classics collection I found Ecocriticism, ecology, and the cultures of antiquity– a four-part book that takes texts from ancient cultures and applies the ecocritical lens we are more used to seeing applied to more contemporary, post-Enlightenment texts. It looks at how classic texts engage with landscapes, ecosystems, animals, extreme weather events and humans within nature.
For some ecocriticism in visual art, Picture ecology: art and ecocriticism in planetary perspective is a perfect starting point. This book follows the exhibition “Nature’s Nation: American Art and Environment” held at Princeton University Art Museum in 2018-19. The book extends the ecocritical work of the exhibition beyond American art, covering the history of Chinese landscape painting, the influence of German naturalist Alexander von Humboldt on Enlightenment art, Buddhist tree-icons in Japan and representations of Saint Francis. The variety of mediums and topics covered in Picture Ecology provide a comprehensive demonstration of art ecocriticism, and a fantastic introduction to two of the more prominent eco-art historians, Greg Thomas and Sugata Ray.
When faced with existential environmental degradation at the hands of global corporations, what can art achieve? T.J. Demos attempts to answer this with this in Decolonizing Nature: Contemporary Art and the Politics of Ecology using broad analysis of how contemporary artists from all over the globe have responded to environmental disasters, greenwashing, corporate greed and climate-driven displacement. The book captures the current scale, spread and mood of eco-art in its various forms, and the importance of the systemic societal change that this art calls for.
Also, by T.J. Demos is Against the Anthropocene: Visual Culture and Environment Today. This book is a critique of the Anthropocene as a thesis- in name at least- due to the term implicating the entire human race in present ecological and climate crises.The concept of a geological epoch defined by human activity has been much debated within geology (the Anthropocene was rejected as a recognised geological epoch in 2024) and within the arts and humanities, with many bristling at the idea of blame for mass environmental destruction lying with all humans, as Anthro would suggest. Demos analyses how we engage with the Anthropocene by drawing from natural history museums, environmental action and protests, satellite images of Earth and contemporary eco-art. The book picks apart the neatness of a concept that blames our entire species wholesale, while conceding that it can be useful at least the starting point for environmental cultural critique.
For more from our art collections, check out Landscape and power, a collection of essays on our attitudes to environment landscapes through the lens of art- mainly seventeenth- and eighteenth-century European. Or Greenhouse: art, ecology & resistance, the exhibition catalogue for Portuguese representation at the 60th International Art Exhibition, La Biennale di Venezia, which bore the theme ‘Stranieri Ovunque – Foreigners Everywhere’. Images from the exhibition are supplemented by essays on the artist’s and curator’s relationship with space, place and identity- underpinned by how soil, ecology, landscape and species interact with ideas of where a person is ‘from’.
Finally, if you’re interested in architecture then tropical modernism is the movement to get into during Green Libraries week!
Image of Mfantsipim School, Cape Coast
This mid-century movement adapted European aesthetics from modernist and Bauhaus architecture to be suitable for tropical climates and sets a precedent for how architecture can respond to climate change with extreme temperatures becoming a more common occurrence both in and outside of the tropics. Our book Tropical modernism: architecture and independence, from the second floor, which accompanied the exhibition of the same name at the V&A last year (an amazing exhibition – I bought a poster) covers the movement in Ghana and India and the influence of independence on architecture and space, and Who Are Godwin and Hopwood?: Exploring Tropical Architecture in the Age of the Climate Crisis (only available online via SOLO) covers British architects John Godwin and Gillian Hopwood and their work in Nigeria.
You can find the display of all these books and more on the ground floor of our library. These books are just a few from our collections, so be sure to browse SOLO to make the most of the collections here at the Art Library, and in the Bodleian at large!
Full list of books on display:
Bedell, R. The anatomy of nature: geology & American landscape painting, 1825-1875, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press, 2001. Borges S. V. and de Miranda, M. Greenhouse: art, ecology & resistance, Milano, Skira, 2024. Braje, T. J. Understanding imperiled earth: how archaeology and human history inform a sustainable future, Washington, DC, Smithsonian books, 2024. Calder, B. Architecture: from prehistory to climate emergency, London, Pelican, 2021. Chevalier, A. Marinova, E. and Peña-Chocarro, L. (eds.) Plants and people: choices and diversity through time, Oxford, Oxbow Books, 2014. Contreras, D. A. (ed.) The archaeology of human-environment interactions: strategies for investigating anthropogenic landscapes, dynamic environments, and climate change in the human past, New York, NY, Routledge, 2017. Cox, M. Straker, V. and Taylor, D. (eds.) Wetlands: archaeology and nature conservation, London, HMSO, 1995. Demos, T. Decolonizing nature: contemporary art and the politics of ecology, Berlin, Sternberg Press, 2016. Demos, T. J. Against the anthropocene: visual culture and environment today, Berlin, Sternberg Press, 2027. DeWitt, L. (ed.) The triumph of nature: Art Nouveau from the Chrysler Museum of Art, Lewes, D Giles Limited, 2023. Dimbleby, G. W. Ecology and archaeology, London, Edward Arnold, 1977. Dimbleby, G. Plants and archaeology, London and New York, Granada Publishing, 1978. Eshun, E. Black earth rising: colonialism and climate change in contemporary art, London, Thames & Hudson Ltd, 2025. Gaffney, V. L. Europe’s lost world: the rediscovery of Doggerland, York, Council for British Archaeology, 2009. Gaffney, V. L. Thompson, K. Fitch, S. Mapping Doggerland: the Mesolithic landscapes of the southern North Sea, Oxford, Achaeopress, 2007. Haraway, D. Staying with the trouble: making kin in the Chthulucene, Durham, NC, Duke University Press, 2016. Hepper, F. N. Pharaoh’s flowers: the botanical treasures of Tutankhamun, Chicago and London, KWS Pub., 2009 Hessler, S. Sex ecologies, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press, 2021. Ikram, S. Kaiser, J. and Porcier,S. (eds.) The ancient Egyptians and the natural world: flora, fauna, & science, Leiden, Sidestone Press, 2021. Ikram, S. Kaiser, J. and Walker, R. (eds.) Egyptian bioarchaeology: humans, animals, and the environment, Leiden, Sidestone Press, 2015. Kusserow, K. (ed.) and Braddock, A. C. Picture ecology: art and ecocriticism in planetary perspective, Princeton, Princeton University Art Museum, 2021. Levine, L. D. (ed.) Man in nature: historical perspectives on man in his environment, Toronto, Royal Ontario Museum, 1975. Mitchell, W. J. T. Landscape and power, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2002. Schliephake, C. (ed.) Ecocriticism, ecology, and the cultures of antiquity, Lanham, Maryland, Lexington Books, 2017. Sloan, R. and Hargraves, M. A dialogue with nature: romantic landscapes from Britain and Germany, London, Courtauld Gallery and New York, Morgan Library and Museum, 2014. Tosland, B. Who Are Godwin and Hopwood?: Exploring Tropical Architecture in the Age of the Climate Crisis, Basel, Berlin and Boston, Walter de Gruyter GmbH, 2024. Turner,C. Tropical Modernism: Architecture And Independence, London, V&A Publishing, 2024.
This October, we at the Bodleian Art Library are celebrating Black History Month! So, this year’s Art Library graduate trainee, Olly Marshall, has put together a display highlighting some contributions of Black historians, artists, philosophers and other thinkers, in materials available from both here and the Bodleian’s off-site storage facility.
Image of the book display for Black History Month 2025: Standing Firm in Power and Pride.
The theme for this year’s Black History Month – ‘Standing Firm in Power and Pride’ – inspired us to examine examples of Black resistance in the collections – ways in which Black creatives and historians have used their voices and skills to challenge erasure. For example, I have opened Art After Stonewall: 1969-1989 to a page1 featuring both Marsha P. Johnson and Jean-Michel Basquiat, who used their talents and skills in art and community-building to resist oppression. In fact, for a fantastic example of Johnson’s activism, I highly recommend the conversation between filmmakers Tourmaline and Sasha Wortzel, in this volume, in which they discuss, among other things, Johnson’s contributions to providing accommodation for queer youth.
But, there are also lesser-known figures in this display who are nonetheless resisting erasure and injustice in museum and gallery spaces and reimagining the fields of art and archaeology in ways that uplift diverse voices. For example, in Documenting Activism, Creating Change: Archaeology and the Legacy of #MeToo, the authors examine a range of case studies from an intersectional feminist perspective to consider how best to push for progress. Similarly, in Black Feminist Archaeology, Whitney Battle-Baptiste describes a liberatory framework through which we may approach cultural remembrance, defining terms and naming issues in cultural institutions to combat ignorance and misinformation. Then, in The First Black Archaeologist: A Life of Wesley Gilbert, John I. W. Lee pays tribute to a little known, but very important contributor to the American School of Classical Studies at Athens. Gilbert is also an intriguing figure because, as Lee writes, while ‘[i]nterest in African American engagements with Greek and Roman classics […] has burgeoned over the past few decades[,] [t]his interest […] has typically been framed in terms of black receptions of and responses to classical literature, with much less consideration of archaeology or art history’.2 Not only is Lee’s book something of a counterbalance to this trend, as well as to the larger trend of obscuring Black archaeologists in general, but it is also an impressive work of archaeology in itself, as the author travels far and wide to gather the scattered evidence of Gilbert’s life and work.
The book covers of Documenting Activism, Creating Change, Black Feminist Archaeology, and The First Black Archaeologist
I also feel that these themes of whose work is remembered and how, and who has access to cultural institutions fits well with the Malcolm X Steles of Barbara Chase-Riboud. For, while the names of these sculptures suggest they should be seen as monuments, their abstract forms could be interpreted as – among many other resonances – inviting conversation about the fraught relationship between memorial and art, with its potential for commodification.
Barbara Chase-Riboud among three sculptures from her Malcolm X series.
This, furthermore, led me to think about the work of Adrian Piper through this lens. She is represented by several books in the display, including a chapter in Conversation Pieces: Community and Communication in Modern Art, by works in All These Liberations: Women Artists in the Eileen Harris Norton Collection, and Adrian Piper: Race, Gender, and Embodiment. A key theme of her work is questioning who is allowed a place within the art establishment, whose art is remembered, and how is that remembrance mediated? This is very obviously part of her installation Four Intruders Plus Alarm Systems, which is comprised of a dark room, with images of Black men on the walls. These are accompanied by recordings of racist comments that range from ignorant to nakedly hostile. Then, in other of her works, Piper draws upon her complex experience as a white-passing Black woman in the art world. John P. Bowles, in Adrian Piper, explains how this thread of autobiography in Piper’s art and her use of challenging language and second-person address has led some critics to simplify her body of work, casting the artist as ‘an angry [B]lack woman’ or a ‘distraught victim, lashing out unfairly at liberal museum-goers who might otherwise take her side.’ But, part of the power of Piper’s work is in resisting stereotype and constructing space for questioning systems and sitting with discomfort.
Book covers for Conversation Pieces, All These Liberations, and Adrian Piper.
The book Negro Building: Black Americans in the World of Fairs and Museums also engages with these issues, examining the challenges and benefits of representing Black history in exhibition spaces. One of those challenges has been the building of these spaces or adapting of already existing ones (such as the conversion of the Lorraine Motel into the National Civil Rights Museum, Memphis) and this links well with Here: Where the Black Designers Are. In this volume, prolific graphic designer Cheryl Holmes Miller details her own efforts to foster inclusion in her field – starting with her 1985 graduate thesis, ‘Transcending the Problems of the Black Graphic Designer in the Marketplace’ – and how such activism can create spaces that are ‘more rigorous, more functional, and more accessible for everyone.’3
Similarly, the artists in Shining Lights: Black Women Photographers in 1980s-90s Britain, also had to contend with exclusionary institutions and some of their work and writing reflects this. In particular, Glynis Nelsen’s 1985 essay featured in the volume speaks to the economic and cultural barriers faced by Black women artists in representing themselves and having the representation respected – and how community and the pooling of resources are one way to combat this. This essay is striking in how, despite being forty years old (this distance in time being clear from the technologies she names as contemporary to her writing) the issues discussed are just as prominent now.
Covers for the books Shining Lights, Phenomenal Difference, and Towards an African Canadian Art History.
I also think that this volume is very valuable for specifically addressing Black British experiences. For, it is important to remember the indelible work of Black artists and resistance movements across the globe. For this reason, I thought it important to include books such as Phenomenal Difference: A Philosophy of Black British Art and Towards an African Canadian Art History: Art, Memory, and Resistance.
Furthermore, attention must, of course be paid to the history of resistance on the African continent, represented here by The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994. I was particularly fascinated by the essay in this volume, ‘Colonial Pretense and African Resistance, or Subversion Subverted: Commemorative Textiles in Sub-Saharan Africa’, given my interest in the relationship between memorialisation and resistance. In this chapter, John Picton details how Asante and Yoruba weavers use wax cloth patterns to commemorate individuals or events, or to encapsulate ideas such as proverbs. In doing so, these weavers take ‘an inept Dutch imitation of Indonesian batik’4 cloth and create from it a richly meaningful artform. The history of wax prints is a good example of how, as with the art of Adrian Piper and of Barbara Chase-Riboud, much African art resists facile interpretation. Some have attempted to connect the origins of modern African art to European movements, but the evidence does not support this. As Chika Okeke argues, the modern African art scene exists more in spite of rather than because of European traditions. This is because ‘wherever art did feature in the colonial curriculum, it was restricted to the notion of craft’. For schools were ‘mainly concerned with fulfilling the colonial powers’ need for low-level manpower’. Indeed, given the influence of indigenous art on movements such as Cubism and Surrealism, it might be easier to argue that the artistic canon of the Global North owes much more to Africa than vice versa.5
Similarly in African Connections: Archaeological Perspectives on Africa and the Wider World, Peter Mitchell highlights the multifarious routes that African peoples’ trading relationships have taken over the course of the continent’s long, long history, and how those relationships were hardly if ever unidirectional. For example, the sheer amount of crafts and agricultural items that were both exported from and imported to African locations – many of which we now take for granted in our modern, extremely connected world – is nothing short of overwhelming.6 Mitchell also rightly takes pains to highlight the diversity of cultures that call Africa home and to debunk the myth of African homogeneity largely fostered by European minds.
The length and richness of African history is also attested to by Andrew Smith in First People: The Lost History of the Khoisan. In this accessibly written, but deeply researched book, Smith casts a spotlight on a chapter of Black history unknown to most: namely that of the Khoisan people who lived in what is now Namibia, Botswana and South Africa. Not only does he explain why this slice of human history is so useful and fascinating – from linguistic analyses to explorations of farming and craft techniques – but he links the lack of interest in this story directly to colonial erasure. In doing so, he demonstrates, again like many of the other authors and figures in this display, that remembrance is an important step in resistance.
Book covers for The Short Century, African Connections, and First People.
I cannot recommend these titles enough. It has been a joy to have this opportunity to explore and share the work of so many fantastic Black artists and writers for this project, and I hope that you also find the chance to be fascinated and challenged by them.
Bibliography
T. Akers, ‘Reverend Joyce McDonald: ‘Art was like therapy for me’, The Art Newspaper, vol.33, no. 381, September 2025, p.14 and p.16.
T. R. Aldridge and S. Belsheim (eds.), All These Liberations: Women Artists in the Eileen Harris Norton Collection, Santa Monica CA, Eileen Harris Norton Collection, 2024.
C. Basualdo (ed.), Barbara Chase-Riboud: The Malcolm X Steles, New Haven CT, 2013.
W. Battle-Baptiste, Black Feminist Archaeology, Walnut Creek CA, Left Coast Press, 2011.
J. Billard, ‘Uptown and downtown re-imagined’, The Art Newspaper, vol.33, no. 381, September 2025, p.8 and pp.10-11.
E. Boone et al., Towards an African Canadian History: Art, Memory, and Resistance, Concord ON, Captus Press, 2019.
J. P. Bowles, Adrian Piper: Race, Gender, and Embodiment, Durham NC, Duke University Press, 2011.
M. Cheale, ‘A fresh lesson in art history at the Academy’, The Art Newspaper, vol.33, no. 381, September 2025, p.52.
H. Cobb and K. Hawkins (eds.), Documenting Activism, Creating Change: Archaeology and the Legacy of #MeToo, Bicester, Archaeopress Publishing Ltd., 2025.
T. R. Dahmani and J. Gregory (eds.), Shining Lights: Black Women Photographers in 1980s-’90s Britain, London, MACK & Autograph, 2024.
O. Enwezor (ed.), The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994, Munich, Prestel, 2001.
J. M. Hayes et al., Augusta Savage: Renaissance Woman, Jacksonville FL, Cummer Museum of Art, 2018.
C. D. Holmes-Miller, Here: Where the Black Designers Are: A Life in Advocacy, New York, Princeton Architectural Press, 2024.
E. Jenkins and K. Sharp, Black Artists in America: From the Great Depression to Civil Rights, Memphis TN, Dixon Gallery and Gardens, 2021.
G. H. Kessler, Conversation Pieces: Community and Communication in Modern Art, Berkeley CA, University of California Press, 2004.
J. I. W. Lee, The First Black Archaeologist: A Life of John Wesley Gilbert, New York, Oxford University Press, 2022.
P. Mitchell, African Connections: An Archaeological Perspective on Africa and the Wider World, Walnut Creek CA, AltaMira Press, 2005.
Nikitag94, ‘Barbara Chase-Riboud cropped.jpg’, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Barbara_Chase-Riboud_cropped.jpg, (accessed 22 October 2025)
C. Okeke, ‘Modern African Art’, in O. Enwezor (ed.), The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994, Munich, Prestel, 2001, pp.29-36.
J. Picton, ‘Colonial Pretense and African Resistance, or Subversion Subverted: Commemorative Textiles in Sub-Saharan Africa’, in O. Enwezor (ed.), The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994, Munich, Prestel, 2001, pp. 159-174.
C. Porterfield, ‘The Armory Show puts spotlight on the South’, The Art Newspaper, vol.33, no. 381, September 2025, p.1 and p.7.
L. Raicovich, Culture Strike: Art and Museums in an Age of Protest, London, Verso, 2021.
D. Sawyer et al., Art After Stonewall: 1969-1989, Columbus OH, Columbus Museum of Art, 2019.
A. Smith, First People: The Lost History of the Khoisan, Cape Town, South Africa, 2022.
Tourmaline and S. Wortzel, ‘Marsha P. Johnson: A Conversation Between Tourmaline and Sasha Wortzel’, in Art After Stonewall: 1969-1989, Columbus OH, Columbus Museum of Art, 2019, pp.128-131.
L. Wainwright, Phenomenal Difference: A Philosophy of Black British Art, Liverpool, Liverpool University Press, 2017.
M. O. Wilson, Negro Building: Black Americans in the World of Fairs and Museums, Berkeley, University of California Press, 2020.
D. Sawyer et al., Art After Stonewall: 1969-1989, Columbus OH, Columbus Museum of Art, 2019, pp.206-207 ↩︎
J. I. W. Lee, The First Black Archaeologist: A Life of John Wesley Gilbert, New York, Oxford University Press, 2022, p. 4 ↩︎
C. Williams, ‘Foreword by Crystal Williams’, in Here: Where the Black Designers Are, New York, Princeton Architectural Press, 2019,pp.9-10 ↩︎
J. Picton, ‘Colonial Pretense and African Resistance, or Subversion Subverted: Commemorative Textiles in Sub-Saharan Africa’, in O. Enwezor (ed.), The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994, Munich, Prestel, 2001, p. 160. ↩︎
C. Okeke, ‘Modern African Art’, in O. Enwezor (ed.), The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994, Munich, Prestel, 2001, pp.29-36. ↩︎
P. Mitchell, African Connections: Archaeological Perspectives on Africa and the Wider World, Walnut Creek CA, AltaMira Press, 2005, pp.13-14: ‘Coffee, sorghum, millet, guinea fowl, and donkeys are some of those domesticated in Africa but now also grown or kept elsewhere; sheep, goats, camels, horses, wheat, barley, chickens, bananas, rice, some kinds of yam, maize, and cassava are among those with extra-African origins. […] Glassware, leather items, and artifacts and ingots of metal flowed along the same routes’. ↩︎
Monday 5th May saw the opening of the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s latest Costume Institute exhibition – Superfine: Tailoring Black Style – and with it, another Met Gala! Like the Met, we at the Art Library have decided to celebrate Black fashion with a display of items from across the Bodleian’s collections.
Superfine: Tailoring Black Style book display. Image Credit: Iona Spark
As a topic, this is extremely fertile ground for exploration, combining history of fashion, decorative arts, fine art, social history, philosophy, and literature. Nowhere is this more apparent than in Slaves to Fashion: Black Dandyism and the Styling of Black Diasporic Identity by Monica L. Miller. This book – which serves as the main inspiration for the Met’s exhibition – is a rich, nuanced and fascinating examination of key moments in the development of the Black dandy as a popular cultural figure and explores the tensions that this figure evokes. As Miller states, ‘the dandy is a figure who exists in the space between masculine and feminine, homosexual and heterosexual, seeming and being, even when not specifically racialized’.1
Book cover for Slaves to Fashion, depicting Iké Udé posing in profile upon a chaise, wearing a dark frock coat with light gloves and a buttonhole
One person who consciously plays with these boundaries and who is intimately tied up with the Met’s exhibition is Nigerian artist, Iké Udé. Not only is his work featured in the exhibition and not only did he contribute an epilogue to the exhibition catalogue, but one of his photographic self-portraits graces the cover of Miller’s book. This photo provides an excellent example of how Udé practices the ‘discipline’ of dandyism – as he calls it2 – in both his art and his appearance. He is further represented in the display through the sartorial photography catalogue Beyond Decorum: The Photography of Iké Udé. In this collection, Udé explores the boundaries between his subjects’ outward seeming and inner worlds as deep, dark secrets are stitched to the insides of their clothes.
Furthermore, as a Nigerian artist who largely resides and practices in the US, Udé is in some ways representative of another ‘thread’ of Miller’s exploration – namely, the complex relationship between blackness and Africa as cultural constructs. She discusses how racialised colonialism can lead to a perceived collapsing of many African diasporic experiences, but how, at the same time, Black people in the diaspora have been able to use these constructs in order to build their own styles and identities. This could be seen at the Met Gala through the inclusion of subtle cowrie detailing on Lewis Hamilton’s outfit, and in the books of the display through Mickaël Kra: Jewellery Between Paris Glamour and African Tradition, for which Kra takes inspiration from the jewellery-making practices of various hunter-gatherer peoples of southern Africa.
Then, in African Dress: Fashion, Agency and Performance, the opposite side of this exchange is presented through essays detailing the style experiences of a variety of communities throughout the African continent, and in the issue of African Arts on the display, including an article about the Sapeuses – the feminine equivalent of the more famous, besuited Sapeur Congolese subculture. Also, I have included here a photo by Kinshasa-based photographer Justin Makangara of a man whose striking combination of Congolese adornment with western-style garments and accessories illustrates the ways that some African communities are forging their own style paths.
Photo of a Congolese Sapeur wearing a suit jacket, cap and sunglasses, decorated heavily with beads and shells. Image Credit: Justin Mkangara. Via Wikimedia Commons
Yinka Shonibare – represented here through catalogues for his Fabric-ation and Double Dutch exhibitions – similarly uses his sculptural dioramas, sumptuously dressed in African wax prints and often recreating the silhouettes and poses of famous white historical figures and events, to push past the boundaries and stereotypes created by colonialist narratives. Shonibare’s use of wax prints is a symbolically loaded one, not only because of the contrast between the stereotypically African patterns and the Europeanness of the clothing, but because that fabric contains within it a complex but often overlooked story of colonial appropriation and adoption. Wax prints originated in Indonesia, were then mass-produced first by the Dutch and then even more prolifically by the British, and finally sold to West African buyers.
Photo of Shonibare’s sculpture Big Boy from Double Dutch, page 62
Through these works he makes statements about identity construction, cultural appropriation and consumerism in ways that play out interestingly with Miller’s work on Black dandyism. For example, her exploration of the fraught nature of using extravagance for defiance is echoed by Shonibare when discussing his work: ‘In order to have aristocratic freedom to indulge, others need to be colonised. Fine art is excess par excellence. It is not going to emancipate you in any direct way.3 He also addresses the interplay of dandyism, race and class directly in Double Dutch through the photograph series ‘Diary of Victorian Dandy’.
In Afro-Fabulations: The Queer Drama of Black Life by Tavia Nyong’o– available as an ebook via SOLO and via the QR code in the display – the author discusses the same problem of high art, but with a fashionable twist. In the chapter ‘Critical Shade: The Angular Logics of Black Appearance’, Nyong’o dissects Trajal Harrell’s solo dance piece Twenty Looks or Paris Is Burning at the Judson Church, Size Small. Harrell, in this piece, incorporates and dissects elements of both high fashion catwalks and the New York ballroom culture inspired by the same. Nyong’o in turn highlights the tensions of Harrell ‘performing in the avant-garde milieu that was once the stuff of vogueing fantasy4’ and explores possible interpretations of this tension.
Online book cover for Afro-Fabulations
In The Politics of Black Joy: Zora Neale Hurston and Neo-Abolitionism, Lindsey Stewart similarly examines the trials and limits of liberation – for example, how both Black joy and Black tragedy can be weaponised by white institutions to simplify African-American narratives into either abject tragedies or enchanting fables. Stewart uses the works of Zora Neale Hurston, blended with the art of famous contemporary figures such as Beyoncé and stories from her own experience as jumping-off points, and I thought this a fitting addition to this display as the 1934 Zora Neale Hurston essay, “The Characteristics of Negro Expression” was one of the inspirations for the Met’s exhibition. As Stewart details, one of Hurston’s key preoccupations was, in ways sometimes controversial, challenging the ‘tradition of tragic southern Black representation’5
Saint Adeline by Kehinde Wiley, a stained-glass work depicting a haloed young black man in light-coloured denim, on a dark blue background.
Kehinde Wiley likewise challenges pervading narratives applied to African Americans – especially their exclusion from the canon of western art. In his portraits, he poses his black subjects in imitation of a variety of famous ‘Old Master’ paintings and stained-glass windows, constructing new meanings from their symbolic resonances. However, I thought Wiley’s art particularly works in a display on Black style and especially dandyism because of his keen interest in Black masculine identity – and especially how young Black men construct themselves. This can be seen in the participatory nature of some of his paintings and glassworks, in which he invited his models to choose their own outfits and which paintings they would like to copy. In this way, while the streetwear of these men might seem completely divorced from the flamboyance of a dandy, the two can be brought into conversation in Wiley’s art through a mediated process of self-fashioning and evidence of assertive masculine vanity. Furthermore, Wiley’s paintings also evoke connection with dandyism through his use of floral designs for his backgrounds, inspired by the prints of William Morris, a key contributor to the English Aesthetic movement.
The cover of Fashioning Masculinities with a photo of Omar Victor Diop in Regency era clothing.
Unfortunately, there isn’t space to write in-depth about every book in a single blog post, and I wish I could do so to recommend these fantastic books even further, but here I will quickly emphasise just a few. The exhibition catalogue for the V+A’s Fashioning Masculinities exhibition, while its focus is menswear more generally, pays tribute to the indispensability of Black male style, and features black men literally front and centre with a portrait of Omar Victor Diop on the front cover and other famous figures such as Marcus Rashford and Prince inside. Then, in The Birth of Cool, Carol Tulloch, like Monica Miller uses a key central idea – in this case, the concept of “cool” –to organise a tracing of Black style narratives through time, and, like Lindsey Stewart, she also draws upon personal experience in examining these narratives.
The cover of The Woman in the Zoot Suit, depicting three Pachuca women being arrested.
Finally, no display on Black style would be complete without the iconic zoot suit, represented here not only through Zoot Suit: The Enigmatic Career of an Extreme Style, but also through The Woman in the Zoot Suit:Gender, Nationalism, and the Cultural Politics of Memory which focuses specifically on the style’s proliferation into the Pachuco subculture and specifically among Pachuca women.
I hope you have enjoyed this exploration of Black fashion inspired by these books and by the Met Gala as much as I enjoyed researching them. These are just a selection of the books available on Black history, art, and style in the Bodleian Libraries and I hope you will use it as a launch pad for further research on the subject.
Bibliography
A. Braun, M. Kra, and F. Vormese, Mickaël Kra: Jewellery Between Paris Glamour and African Tradition (Stuttgart: Arnoldsche, 2006).
S. Coulson, Lilley, C., and Y. Shonibare, Yinka Shonibare MBE: Fabric-ation Exhibition Guide (Wakefield: Yorkshire Sculpture Park, 2013).
N. Gainer, Vintage Black Glamour: Gentlemen’s Quarters (London: Rocket 88, 2016).
T. Garrard, African Gold: Jewellery and Ornaments From Ghana, Cote d’Ivoire, Mali and Senegal in the Collection of the Gold of Africa Barbier-Mueller Museum in Cape Town (Munich: Prestel, 2011).
R. Garelick, ‘America’s Premier Dandy Doesn’t Want the Title’, The New York Times, New York, The New York Times Company, 2025. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/28/style/met-gala-ike-ude-black-dandyism.html (Accessed: 07 May 2025).
T. Golden, Black Male: Representations of Masculinity in Contemporary American Art (New York: Whitney Museum of American Art, 1994)
K. Hansen and M. Soyini (eds.), African Dress: Fashion, Agency and Performance (Oxford: Berg, 2013)
J. King, ‘The Art of Masculinity’, Colorlines, Oakland, CA; New York City, Race Forward, 2015, https://colorlines.com/article/art-masculinity/ (Accessed: 07 May 2025).
K. Laciste, ‘Practical Work: Sapeuses (Women Sapeurs) in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of the Congo’, African Arts, vol. 56, no. 4, 2023, pp.62-79.
G. Lamia (ed.), Kehinde Wiley: Peintre de L’Épopée (Gand: Snoeck, 2020).
J. Makangara, ‘Justin Makangara’, Congo in Conversation, Hyères, Fondation Carmignac 2021 https://congoinconversation.fondationcarmignac.com/en/journalists/justin-makangara (Accessed: 08 May 2025).
J. Marsh, Black Victorians: Black People in British Art, 1800-1900 (Aldershot: Lund Humphries, 2005).
M. McCollom, The Way We Wore: Black Style Then (New York: Glitterati Incorporated, 2006).
M. McCurdy, Kehinde Wiley: A Portrait of a Young Gentleman (San Marino, California: The Huntington Library, Art Museum, and Botanical Gardens, 2022).
R. McKever and C. Wilcox (eds.), Fashioning Masculinities: The Art of Menswear (London: V&A Publishing, 2022).
K. Mercer, ‘Art That is Ethnic in Inverted Commas’, Frieze, London, Frieze Publishing Ltd., 1995, https://www.frieze.com/article/art-ethnic-inverted-commas (Accessed: 07 May 2025).
T. Muriu, Camo (Los Angeles, California: Chronicle Chroma, 2024).
T. Nyong’o, Afro-Fabulations: The Queer Drama of Black Life (New York: New York University Press, 2019)
K. Peiss, Zoot Suit: The Enigmatic Career of an Extreme Style (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2011).
R. Powell, Cutting a Figure: Fashioning Black Portraiture (Chicago, Ill.; London: University of Chicago Press, 2008).
C. Ramírez, The Woman in the Zoot Suit: Gender, Nationalism, and the Cultural Politics of Memory, Durham; London: Duke University Press, 2009).
L. Roach, How to Build a Fashion Icon: Notes on Confidence From the World’s Only Image Architect (New York: Abrams Image, 2024).
D. Rodgers, ‘Everything You Need To Know About The Met Gala 2025’, Vogue, Condé Nast, New York, 2025 https://www.vogue.co.uk/article/met-gala (Accessed: 07 May 2025).
Y. Shonibare and others, Yinka Shonibare: Double Dutch (Rotterdam : Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen ; [Vienna] : Kunsthalle Wien ; Rotterdam : NAi Publishers ; New York : D.A.P./Distributed Art Publishers, 2004).
L. Stewart, The Politics of Black Joy: Zora Neale Hurston and Neo-Abolitionism, (Evanston, Illinois : Northwestern University Press, 2021).
E. Tsai, C. Choi, and K. Wiley, Kehinde Wiley: A New Republic (Munich: DelMonico, 2015).
C. Tulloch, Black Style (London: V&A Publications, 2004).
C. Tulloch, The Birth of Cool: Style Narratives of the African Diaspora, Oxford: Bloomsbury Academic, 2016).
Victoria and Albert Museum, An introduction to the Aesthetic Movement, https://www.vam.ac.uk/articles/an-introduction-to-the-aesthetic-movement?srsltid=AfmBOop4qQvK1h4Jr7J5AGtwvgeHxKr_XFZjWxmsxcVbtyl-5WvKEGdF (Accessed: 07 May 2025).
S. White and G. White, Stylin’: African American Expressive Culture From its Beginnings to the Zoot Suit (Ithaca, N.Y.; London: Cornell University Press, 1998).
K. Wiley, Kehinde Wiley: Saint Louis, (Culver City, California: Roberts Projects, 2019).
Miller, Monica L., Slaves to Fashion: Black Dandyism and the Styling of Black Diasporic Identity (Durham ; London: Duke University Press, 2009), p. 6. ↩︎
R. Garelick, ‘America’s Premier Dandy Doesn’t Want the Title’, The New York Times, New York, The New York Times Company, 2025. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/28/style/met-gala-ike-ude-black-dandyism.html (Accessed: 07 May 2025). ↩︎
K. Mercer, Art That is Ethnic in Inverted Commas, Frieze, London, Frieze Publishing Ltd., 1995, https://www.frieze.com/article/art-ethnic-inverted-commas (Accessed: 07 May 2025). ↩︎
T. Nyong’o, Afro-Fabulations: The Queer Drama of Black Life (New York: New York University Press, 2019), p.30 ↩︎
L. Stewart, The Politics of Black Joy: Zora Neale Hurston and Neo-Abolitionism, (Evanston, Illinois : Northwestern University Press, 2021), p.47 ↩︎
Ukrainian Artists book display, marking one year since the Russian invasion (24 January 2023) Photo credit Jamie Copeland
Since the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine (24 January 2022), the Bodleian Art, Archaeology and Ancient World Library has maintained a book display celebrating Ukrainian culture and presenting a selection of the material held in our collections that can enrich awareness of Ukraine’s art, architecture, archaeology and history. It was also intended to refresh this display periodically, both to mark events such as Ukraine Independence Day and to guard against the impression that attention has moved on. The change of material is also an opportunity to address areas that may not have been as prominent in previous displays, while drawing on the expanding collection and resources available.
The first anniversary of the invasion was an obvious moment both to reflect upon the events of the past year and to address some of the issues that I have become aware of. One of the difficulties that I had encountered was in finding material featuring contemporary artists and their responses to the ‘special military operation’ and the preceding near-decade of Russian hostilities. Although many cultural institutions and journals have commemorated the war many of the articles and institutional resources remain online only. I was able, however, to find a physical issue of the journal Artforum that has a description of an artist’s experience of the onset of the war and images of their reaction to it.
Artforum international. v.60: no.8(2022: Apr.)
Nikita Kadan. The Shadow on the Ground.
The second issue that I wanted the display to address was a response to Putin’s speech denying Ukraine’s statehood, and his preceding essay “On the historical unity of Russians and Ukrainians”, something I had considered during the display’s previous iteration but had learned more about over the last year. The publication ‘Postcolonial Europe?: essays on post-communist literatures and cultures’ was useful in this regard, especially the chapter titled ‘Ukrainian Culture after Communism’.
One of the major figures of Ukrainian nationhood is Mikhail Hrushevsky, historian and President of the Central Rada (Central Council of Ukraine) before its overthrow by German backed forces in April 1918. Hrushevsky continued his efforts to claim a historical legitimacy for Ukraine independent of Russia for the rest of his life, despite mounting repression. One of his more popular works was The Illustrated history of Ukraine, a single volume edition derived from his ten volume Survey of the History of the Ukrainian People, the first major work on Ukrainian history. The early 1913 version can be contrasted with the revised, post-independence 1997 edition.
Mikhail Grushevskīĭ . History of the Ukrainian People. 1913/1997
State Emblem of the UNR, adopted by the Central Rada, 1918
Origin of the Cossacks. 1913 ed.
The Decline of the Cossacks and Ukraine. 1997 ed.
A complication in selecting publications for the display was the definition of a Ukrainian. From various perspectives (for example frequent border and regime shifting) the list could include people of Ukrainian heritage, such as Hrushevsky himself, who was born in Chełm, then part of Poland subject to Imperial Russia, to a family of the Ukrainian aristocracy. There are also artists such as Abraham Manievich, born in Belarus to a Jewish family, who studied in Kiev and was a co-founder of the Ukrainian Academy of Fine Arts. Although primarily resident in Kiev, he travelled throughout the Russian Empire and Europe before emigrating to the United States after the murder of his son in a pogrom during the Russian Civil War. A similar example is Sonia Delauney, also Jewish, born in Odessa, but who moved to St. Petersburg in her early childhood. She then moved to Paris at the age of fifteen. Would it be justifiable to include an important artist, the first living female artist to have a retrospective exhibition of her work at the Louvre (1964), just because her birthplace was in Ukraine although her education and career took place abroad? One of the quotes about her work addressed the subject of Ukraine as a formative influence upon her work.
“About 1911 I had the idea of making for my son, who had just been born, a blanket composed of bits of fabric like those I had seen in the houses of Ukrainian peasants. When it was finished, the arrangement of the pieces of material seemed to me to evoke cubist conceptions and we then tried to apply the same process to other objects and paintings.” Sonia Delaunay.[12]
Sonia Delaunay. Compositions for a binding of ‘Der Sturm’.
The recent exhibition In the Eye of the Storm: Modernism in Ukraine, 1900-1930s (Madrid, Thyssen-Bornemisza National Museum, 29/11/2022 – 30/04/2023) displayed works from their the museum’s collection in conjunction with works from the national collections of Ukraine; this was a response to the Museums for Ukraine initiative, providing a cultural protest to both the invasion and Russia’s denial of a separate Ukraine culture. In the accompanying publication Francesca Thyssen-Bornemisza addresses this subject, stating that the war is ‘not only about controlling territory, but also about owning the narrative’. In the introduction, the curator and art historian Konstantin Akinsha traces the history of modern Ukraine from the culturally tolerant early years of the Bolsheviks, through the terror of the Stalinist years, the relative calm of Khrushchev and the re-emergence of Ukraine as a nation state. In parallel with this political history runs a cultural history with the idealism of Ukrainian modernism experiencing both genocidal suppression and Russian appropriation as the Western art markets made modernism useful to the USSR, then the post-Soviet attempt to rediscover and exhibit the ‘Ukrainian Avant-Garde’. The lives of various artists, as they experienced fates ranging from execution, imprisonment, exile to suppression,were restricted as they saw their works confined to the ‘Spetsfond’ a sealed archive for works produced by ‘formalists’, ‘nationalists’ and other ‘criminals’. In the Eye of the Storm is broadly divided into parts, with the first three – on Kyiv, Karkhiv, and Odesa – following the various regions and associated schools with distinctive but connected experiences as they attempted to preserve the expression of their selves in the face of an overwhelming hegemonic power. The fourth part, ‘Aftermath’, follows the lives of the surviving artists. An essay, ‘From Oblivion to Glory’, discusses the Spetsfond and its function as an inadvertent resource for the subsequent study of Ukrainian art; with works held by the State Ukrainian Museum then divided among five categories, determining (for example) whether they could be exhibited, used for scientific work or transferred. The final paragraph of the book notes:
‘Almost all works from the spetsfond were allocated to the fifth group, the so-called zero category, with the majority being taken out of their frames and rolled up. As luck would have it, this eventually saved them from destruction. Because the zero category did not belong to the Museum’s primary collection it never featured in official reports and was not subject to further checks. All works from this group, therefore, remained intact in the Museum’s vaults to be discovered by future generations of curators and art historians.’
Vladimir Kruglov. Zinaida Serebryakova (2004) Book cover.
Zinaida Serebryakova. On the Terrace in Kharkov. 1919. Novosibirsk State Art Museum, Novosibirsk
With this in mind I wanted to display the work of artists not restricted by artistic schools or questions of identity, but to focus on their response to Ukraine as a nation. Zinaida Serebryakova, was born in Kharkiv in 1884, her family prominent in the artistic establishment of the Russian Empire. She spent much of her life in exile, often in near poverty after the death of her husband and her reluctance to conform to depicting the preferred subjects of the Soviet establishment, preferring instead to paint landscapes, scenes of rural life and domestic portraits, often of her children. Unable to afford the materials for her preferred technique of oil painting she then worked with cheaper materials such as pencil and charcoal, learning to sketch rapidly. In 1924 she was given a commission for a mural in Paris, leaving her four children under the care of her mother. On completion of this work she was unable to return to the Soviet Union and was separated from her family, although she retained her Soviet citizenship until the Nazi occupation forced her to abandon it in order to gain a Nansen passport. In 1947 she was granted French citizenship and was able to bring two of her children to Paris but was unable to meet the rest of her family until the so-called Khrushchev Thaw. In 1960 she was reunited with her daughter, now an artist at the Moscow Art Theatre. Her daughter was able to help arrange a series of major exhibitions in Moscow, Leningrad and Kyiv, which took place in 1966. The success of these established Serebryakova’s reputation in her homeland after half a life in exile. She died in 1968.
I chose to show, as openings in the book display, several paintings from Serebryakova’s earlier work. On the Terrace in Kharkov (1919) shows a peaceful family scene, with the strong use of blue and yellow, emphasizing the theme of Ukraine. The below landscapes of Ukrainian countryside, with sunflowers, rolling plains, and Crimean hills offering a counterpoint to the images of devastation we have seen since the invasion.
Zinaida Serebriakova. Autumn. 1910.
Zinaida Serebriakova, The Shoots of Autumn Crops. 1908. Tretyakov Gallery.
Zinaida Serebriakova. Crimea Landscape. 1913.
Contrasting with Serebryakova’s peaceful landscapes, the paintings of David Burliuk have the unstable energy typical of Futurism. Born in Riabushky, part of the Kharkov Governorate, Burliuk’s family was a mixture of Ukrainian Cossacks with a Belarussian mother. His portrait of fellow futurist Vasily Kamensky draws on the Byzantine tradition of icon painting normally used to depict the divine serenity of saints, an effect undermined by the clash of colours and almost vibrating shapes. The painting Dnieper Rapids is barely recognisable as a landscape, the land and sky merging into broken reds. Burliuk’s early life was a flurry of travel through Russia and Europe and a string of movements and manifestos. After the end of the Bolsheviks’ initial tolerance for dissent by prominent figures on the left he was forced to flee via Japan, eventually settling on Long Island, New York. Despite persistent campaigning he was refused permission to revisit the USSR until the Khrushchev years.
The revival of interest in Soviet avant-garde movements following the Khrushchev Thaw notwithstanding, the art markets of the West had only an outside view of the influences prevalent in their creation. In his above-mentioned essay, Konstantin Akinsha quotes Oleh Ilnytzkyz, an early proponent of Ukranian Futurism: “The goal is not to place a new ‘Ukrainian’ straitjacket on cultural activities in the empire, but to find a way to do justice to the variety of sources and the myriad of cultural influences that flowed from so many directions. The recognition of Burliuk, [Aleksandra] Ekster and [Kazimir] Malevich as Ukrainians does not diminish their relevance for either the imperial (transnational) avant-garde or for strictly Russian culture, where their impact is undeniable.”
David Burliuk. Portrait of the Russian Futurist Poet Vasily Kamensky. 1917. Moscow State Museum
Russian Futurism. Book cover.
David Burliuk. Dniepner Rapids. 1910s. Leningrad State Museum
In a similar attempt to recognise cultural specificity, the National Gallery recently renamed its Degas pastel drawing formally known as Russian Dancers to Ukrainian Dancers.
A brief section titled ‘Note on Transliteration’ (p. 8) in the publication In the eye of the storm: modernism in Ukraine, 1900-1930s (2022) – often used as a resource for this display – discusses one of the issues encountered when discussing Ukraine and its culture. While recognizing the complex identities of artists from this period and area, the project shows that the individuals discussed belong to the narrative of Ukrainian art history. The editors have therefore favoured the transliteration of Ukrainian versions of artists names, except for emigrés with previously well-established reputations in the West. While using various sources to research this book display I found the question of whether to use the Russian or Ukrainian versions of names and places increasingly problematic. Although current resources tend to use Ukrainian names, many/most printed materials, especially those published before the break-up of the USSR, use Russian versions. Many artists themselves may have used Russian versions, including in place names and titles of their works. Unwilling to impose a choice I largely stayed with the version used in the source material I was discussing. The modern history of Ukraine and its relationship with Russia has itself led to several linguistic variations. In contrast with Imperial Russia’ imposition of ‘Russification’ on its provinces, Lenin supported korenizatsiia (nativization), a policy encouraging indigenous cultures and languages as a means of increasing support for the Bolsheviks beyond Russia itself. This policy was abruptly brought to an end by Stalin, whose purges destroyed symbols of Ukrainian culture such as the Kobzars (travelling singers) and had so effective an impact on Ukrainian artists that they became known as the “The Executed Renaissance”.
Alexander Osmekin, Profile and Flowers (1946)
Although later policies were less harsh, the Soviet regime still used imprisonment and censorship as tools to suppress potential dissent. Under these conditions conformity to approved approaches such as ‘Socialist Realism’ became a necessity for many artists, with even coded references such as colour or national symbols risking censure.
Mykhailo Boychuk. Portrait of a Woman. 1909. Lviv National Art Gallery
Like Burliuk, several other artists’ work was influenced by Byzantine icon painting and nativist art. An example is the poignant, folk art-inspired Portrait of a Woman by Mykhailo Boychuk who, in 1936, along with two of his students and four months later his wife, was executed by the NKVD. Boychuk’s work, described by his killers as ‘bourgeois nationalism’ and largely destroyed, was an influence on the later artist and regime opponent Alla Horska, who was herself killed by the KGB in 1970. Much of the work of both of these artists, often in the form of murals, mosaics and other large public works drawing upon Byzantine sources, was destroyed by the Soviet authorities, with some of the work only surviving in preliminary sketches or photographs. Others were preserved by fellow artists and archivists, such as Yaroslava Muzyka, who kept most of the paintings Boychuk left in Lviv after he was forced to abandon them.
Alla Horska. Sketch for a mosaique. 1960(?)
In my attempt to select publications and show artists’ works for the display, and also learn of the fates – exile, appropriation, suppression or attempts to erase from history – of the works and their creators it became impossible not to admire the resilience of people currently struggling to preserve themselves as a nation, however varied. One of the claims put out by the Kremlin, was that Russia and Ukraine are one people separated by a Western coup, thus justifying a ‘special military operation’ to reunite them. Author Andrey Kurkov’s Ukraine diaries, detailing his experiences in Maidan Nezalezhnosti (Independence Square) in Kyiv, as he and others struggled to resist the 2014 attempt to permanently bind Ukraine to Russian vassalage, was also an inspiration for the display. The PEN Ukraine book Treasures of Ukraine, for which Kurkov wrote the foreword, was similarly invaluable in providing a cultural history and a guide to more contemporary work.
The following gallery and list of publications on display can show only a small section of the Art, Archaeology and Ancient World Library’s collection of material celebrating Ukraine.
Gallery
Abstraction In Russia. Book cover.
Ukrainian Modernism. Book cover
Alexandra Exter, Three Female Figures, 1910, National Art Museum of Ukraine.
Yehven Sahaidachny, Going for Water. (National Art Museum of Ukraine)
Treasures of Early Ukrainian Art. Book cover.
Sonia Delauny. Book cover.
Colour Moves: Art and Fashion by Sonia Delaunay. Book cover.
Abraham Manievich. Book cover.
Abraham Manievich. Suburbs of Kiev. (Estate of the artist).
Socialist Realism. Book cover.
Pisankas collection of Yuiy Ferenchuk. Book cover.
Archipenko and the Italian avant garde . Book cover.
Aiwasowski: Maler des Meeres. Book cover.
Ivan Aivazovsky, Sunset at Sea. 1850, Kunstmuseum, Odessa.
Ivan Aivazovsky, Evening in Crimea, 1851,Kunstmuseum, Odessa.
Andreĭ Kurkiov. Ukraine Diaries. Book cover.
Art of Ukrainian Sixties. Book cover..
In the Eye of the Storm. Book cover.
Issakhar Bar Ryback. Stetl (National Art Museum of Ukraine.)
Treasures of Ukraine. Book cover.
Publications on display
Aĭvazovskiĭ, Ivan Konstantinovich. 2011. Aiwasowski : Maler des Meeres / herausgeg Ostfildern : Hatje Cantz
Akinsha, Konstantin. Denysova, Katia. Kashuba-Volvach, Olena. 2022. In the eye of the storm : modernism in Ukraine, 1900-1930s. London : Thames and Hudson
Balashova, Olha [editor-in-chief]. 2021. The art of Ukrainian sixties. Kyiv : Osnovy Publishing
Kurkov, Andrey. 2014. Ukrainian diaries: dispatches from Kiev. London : Harvill Secker
Marko, Olya [Editor] 1991. Spirit of Ukraine : 500 years of painting : selections from the State Museum of Ukrainian Art, Kiev : an exhibition organized by the Winnipeg Art Gallery in honour of the centenary of Ukrainian settlement in Canada. Winnipeg : Winnipeg Art Gallery
Monti, Matteo de. 2011. Colour moves : art and fashion by Sonia Delaunay London : Thames & Hudson
Morozov, A. I. (Aleksandr Ilʹich), 2007 Sot͡srealizm i realism Moskva : Galart
Mudrak, Myroslava M. “The Painted Surface in the Ukrainian Avant-garde: from Facture to Construction.”
Pensler, Alan. 2001. Abraham Manievich, Manchester : Yivo Institute for Jewish Research : Hudson Hills Press
Petrova, Yevgenia. [editor-in chief], 2001. Abstraction in Russia, XX century
St. Petersburg,
Russian futurism : and David Burliuk, “The father of Russian Futurism”
Petrova, Yevgenia [editor-in-chief] 2008. XX century in the Russian Museum: painting, sculpture 1900-2000 Sankt-Peterburg : Palace Editions, 2008.
Pucherová, Dobrota [editor-in-chief]. 2015. Postcolonial Europe? : essays on post-communist literatures and cultures Part V: Between the East and the West: the colonial present — Ukrainian culture after communism: between post-colonial liberation and neo-colonial subjugation. Riabchuk, Mykola. Leiden : Brill Rodopi
Shulʹkevich, M. M. 1982. Kiev : arkhitekturno-istoricheskiĭ ocherk. Kiev : “Budivelʹnyk”
Teboul, David. 2011. I’ve been here once before. Boris Mikhailov interviewed by David Teboul. München : Hirmer
Surudz͡hiĭ, N.M. 2016. Pysanky nashykh babusʹ : zibranni͡a pysanok I͡Urii͡a Ferenchuka = Our grandmothers pysankas : pisankas collection of Yuiy Ferenchuk / avtor proektu ta upori͡adnyk. Chernivt͡si : Misto
Ukrains’kiĭ modernizm 1910-1930 = Ukrainian modernism. 2006, Kyiv : National Art Museum of Ukraine
Versari, Maria Elena (Curator), 2022 Archipenko and the Italian avant garde London : Estorick Foundation
Happy Trans Day of Visibility 2023! For this 31 March, our LGBT+ History Month book display has been rearranged to cast a spotlight on the trans artists included there. As part of this change, I have also added Trap Door: Trans Cultural Production and the Politics of Visibility (MIT Press, 2017), which features many and varied trans artists and theorists presenting interesting and nuanced arguments about the meanings and consequences of visible transness. This book is currently on display open to a page featuring artist, activist, and trans man, Reed Erickson. I thought the title for his self-portrait particularly appropriate for Trans Day of Visibility: I am fire, I am Wind, I AM BEING All that YOU IS SEEING.
I have also opened the volume Queer!? (Zwolle, 2019) to a page about the trans masculine Russian-Hungarian performance artist and painter, El Kazovsky; and, from Jonathan Weisberg’s Art after Stonewall: 1969-1989 (2019), I have centred an image of Marsha P. Johnson alongside a conversation about her between filmmaker, Sasha Wortzel and writer and trans activist, Tourmaline. While the relationship of drag performers like Marsha to transness is complicated – some identify as trans and some do not – their importance to trans movements cannot be denied, and their representation of fluid gender performance complements this theme.
Similarly, beginning in the 1970s, Nan Goldin, represented in this display through Nan Goldin, by Guido Costa (Phaidon, 2005), drew the attention of the art world to drag queens and transgender life. This book features on its cover her photograph Jimmy Paulette & Misty in a Taxi, NYC (1991) – just one of the many images she recorded of her drag queen friends.
Then, while explicit trans representation is extremely difficult to find in ancient history, I thought that the page entitled ‘A Gender Changing Goddess’ from Richard Parkinson’s A Little Gay History (2013) provides a concise introduction to ancient evidence for gender variance.
I hope that you too have enjoyed this brief look into trans representation in the collections at the Sackler Library!
LGBT+ History Month 2023
‘Behind the Lens’ Book Display
by Ashley Parry
It’s February already! In the UK, this means that it’s LGBTQ+ History Month, which offers an occasion to acknowledge and celebrate the lives of lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans and queer people of all identities throughout the ages. At the Sackler Library, we are marking this month with a display to highlight LGBTQ+ related items in our collections. This year’s theme, Behind the Lens, marks LGBTQ+ people’s contribution to cinema and film not in front of the camera but behind it.
Behind the Lens book display, Sackler Library. Image Credit: Ashley Parry
Some of the publications included in the display: Berenice Abbott; Sunil Gupta’s Queer; Photography’s Orientalism; Robert Mapplethorpe; Outlaw Representation; Blatant Image, in Art After Stonewall. Image Credit: Ashley Parry
Through my research, I was drawn to the work of the trans artist, Wu Tsang, who uses dance and film to explore the theme of perspective in her work.Then, while Andy Warhol looms large over the history of queer art, this month has enabled me to highlight his films specifically. In fact, both Wu Tsang and Andy Warhol illustrate one of the key themes of this display – that LGBTQ+ artist-filmmakers not only question the boundaries between sexualities and genders, but also the boundaries between different forms of artistic expression.
Another artist whose work illustrates this is Derek Jarman (1942-1994), represented in the display by Derek Jarman: Brutal Beauty and also included in Caravaggio in Film and Literature: Popular Culture’s Appropriation of a Baroque Genius. Jarman is best known for his films but has also been very influential in his installation work, and he applied his knowledge of art and art history to his films in their composition and subject matter.
The anthologies on show in the display also illustrate the permeability of genre boundaries, where the work of artists who use film installation is represented alongside that of poets, photographers and fine artists.
For example, Sex Ecologies includes a diverse range of contributions, from photography by filmmaker Pedro Neves Marques to Léuli Eshrāghi’s discussions of Sāmoan sexual and gender diversity. The volume AIDS Riot contains interviews with filmmaker and “TV-guerrilla” Gregg Bordowitz, who “conceived of [‘video’] as the privileged instrument in the de-marginalization of PWAs [People With AIDS]”, alongside discussions of other installation, graphic design, and photographic work from artist collectives in the New York of the 1980s and 1990s. Similarly, in the book Outlaw Representation, Richard Meyer discusses the work of artist and filmmaker, David Wojnarowicz alongside other controversial figures such as photographer Robert Mapplethorpe. The potential for crossover between photography and film gave me the opportunity to include Mapplethorpe’s photographs with those of with those of other queer artists such as Berenice Abbot, and Sunil Gupta. In fact, it is Abbott’s image that has been used for the poster of this display.
Outlaw Representation: Censorship and Homosexuality in Twentieth-Century American Art., p. 262
Robert Mapplethorpe: Self-portrait
Sunil Gupta: Self-portrait (see Gupta’s Queer, p. 86)
Behind the Lens book display: Poster
(A note about the poster for this book display: The image of Berenice Abbott (1898-1991), with camera almost the same height as photographer, is a good fit with this year’s ‘Behind the Lens’ theme. Also aligning itself with the theme, the Courier typeface is typically used for screenplays. As for the text’s colours, I chose Valentino Vecchietti’s tones in his 2021 intersex-inclusive redesign for the Progress Pride Flag at the top of the poster, and the colours of Gilbert Baker’s original 1978 rainbow flag design at the bottom of the poster. Using these colour ranges incorporates as many queer identities as possible without privileging any in particular, while also paying tribute to the past 45 years of queer art history.)
The book Sexuality & Space creates a bridge between the film and photography related books in this display and other fascinating titles on queer theory and architectural criticism, such as Eileen Gray and the Design of Sapphic Modernity, and Queer Space: Architecture and Same-sex Desire. Another related publication, available as an ebook, that is well worth a look is Preservation and Place: Historic Preservation by and of LGBTQ Communities in the United States .
The display’s architecture section, including Sexuality & Space; Eileen Gray and the Design of Sapphic Modernity; Bachelors of a Different Sort; and Queer Space: Architecture and Same-Sex Desire. Image Credit: Ashley Parry.
Although this year’s theme meant that most materials skewed towards the modern, it would be a disservice to the Sackler’s collections and the true diversity of historical experience to concentrate only on this era. For example, no overview of LGBTQ+ history would be complete without the Classical Greek poet Sappho, whose evocations of same-sex desire in her poetry led to the adjective ‘sapphic’ and whose home of Lesbos gives us the word ‘lesbian’. She is included in this display not only through a collection of her poems, but also through Page duBois’s post-modern analysis of her work in Sappho is Burning.
Representing our archaeology collections on the LGBTQ+ front, both L’homosexualité dans le Proche-Orient Ancien et la Bible and Sex and Gender in Ancient Egypt demonstrate the presence of individuals we might now consider queer in the Ancient Near East. The Queer Archaeologies special issue of the periodical World Archaeologies includes various perspectives on how the field can diversify its approach. One of the aspects of reading about LGBTQ+ interpretations of ancient history that I found enlightening is the way they challenge heteronormative cultural customs – questioning whether conclusions about ancient lives are backed up by evidence or based on imported modern assumptions.
One of the pioneers of treating the history of ancient art as a discipline was Johann Joachim Winckelmann (1717-1768). This influential gay philologist is represented by several books in the display, such as Winckelmann – das göttliche Geschlecht and Gay and Lesbian Studies in Art History. Both of these texts examine the ways that Winckelmann’s sexuality informed his approach to the study of ancient art, and contributed to his innovative modes of writing about the subject.
Winckelmann’s work was brought to my attention by Richard Parkinson, author of A Little Gay History, who also kindly donated one of the images accompanying this display.It depicts a still from the set of the film adaptation of E. M. Forster’s Maurice, directed and produced by partners James Ivory and Ismail Merchant. Forster’s inspiration for the novel is also mentioned in the introduction to John Potvin’s Bachelors of a Different Sort as part of his evocations of queer masculine domestic life. The image serves to tie together some of the threads of the display, combining as it does the Egyptian artefacts in the British Museum with a behind-the-scenes look at the work of queer filmmakers.
There’s so much more fascinating material on LGBTQ+ related topics to discover throughout the Sackler Library’s collections, but only so much that could be fit into this display. However, I have included many more titles in the bibliography of this blog post – though, of course, I still have not included everything that the library has to offer!
Ackerman, S., 2005. When heroes love : the ambiguity of eros in the stories of Gilgamesh and David, New York.
Alvarado, L., Evans Frantz, D., Gómez-Barris, M., Ondine Chavovoya, C., et al., 2017, Axis mundo: queer networks in Chicano L.A., Munich.
Anthonissen, A., 2019. Queer!?: Beeldende kunst in Europa 1969-2019 = Visual arts in Europe 1969-2019, Zwolle.
Behdad, A. & Gartlan, L., 2013. Photography’s Orientalism: new essays on colonial representation, Los Angeles.
Betsky, A., 1997. Queer space: architecture and same-sex desire, New York.
Boehringer, S., 2021. Female homosexuality in ancient Greece and Rome, trans. Preger, A., London.
Cann, T., Kinigopoulo, A., Sawyer, D., & Weinburg, J., 2019, Art after Stonewall : 1969-1989, Columbus, OH.
Colomina, B., 1992. Sexuality & space, New York.
Cortjaens, W., Goerlitz, G., & Tobin, R. D., 2017. Winckelmann – Das göttliche Geschlecht Auswahlkatalog zur Ausstellung im Schwulen Museum Berlin, 16. Juni bis 9. Oktober 2017, Petersburg.
Davidson, J. N., 2007. The Greeks and Greek love: a radical reappraisal of homosexuality in ancient Greece, London.
Davis, W., 1994. Gay and lesbian studies in art history, New York.
Dowson, T. A., World Archaeology, Oct. 2000, Vol. 32 (2), ‘Queer Archaeologies’.
DuBois, P., 1995. Sappho is burning, Chicago.
Engel, C., Fenouillat, N., Guitton, A., Di Loreto, B., Loyau, F., Mestrov, I., & Olszewska, A., 2003. AIDS riot: collectifs d’artistes face au Sida = Artist collectives against AIDS, New York, 1987-1994: 12e session de l’École du Magasin, Grenoble.
Gilhuly, K., 2020. Erotic geographies in ancient Greek literature and culture, London.
Graves-Brown, C., 2008. Sex and gender in ancient Egypt: ‘don your wig for a joyful hour’, Swansea.
Gupta, S., 2011. Queer, Munich.
Hessler, S., 2021. Sex ecologies. Cambridge, MA.
Julien, I., 2008. Derek Jarman: brutal beauty. London.
Kuo, J. C., 2013. Contemporary Chinese Art and Film: Theory Applied and Resisted, Washington, D. C.
Mapplethorpe, R., Danto, A. C., Holborn, M., Levas, D., & Smith, P., 2020. Robert Mapplethorpe, London.
Meyer, R., 2003. Outlaw representation: censorship & homosexuality in twentieth-century American art, Boston.
Morelli, A., 2009. Roman Britain and classical deities: gender and sexuality in Roman art, Oxford.
Murphy, J. J., 2012. The black hole of the camera: the films of Andy Warhol, Berkely, CA.
Nardelli, J., 2007. Homosexuality and liminality in the Gilgameš and Samuel, Amsterdam.
Parkinson, R. B., 2013. A little gay history: desire and diversity across the world, London.
Potvin, J., 2014. Bachelors of a different sort : queer aesthetics, material culture and the modern interior in Britain, Manchester.
Rault, J., 2011. Eileen Gray and the design of sapphic modernity: staying in, Farnham.
Römer, T. & Bonjour, L., 2016. L’homosexualité dans le Proche-Orient ancien et la Bible,
Rorato, L., 2014. Caravaggio in film and literature: popular culture’s appropriation of a baroque genius, London.
‘Yes, wonderful things’(?) A Book Display at the Sackler Library
By Susanne Woodhouse
Fig. 1: The Tutankhamun book display at the Sackler Library. Image credit: S. Woodhouse
In 1922, as Egypt moved towards becoming an independent nation, the tomb of Tutankhamun was discovered at Luxor. The excavation of the tomb by Howard Carter and his team developed into a media event and was photographed by Harry Burton (1879–1940), from the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. The prints and negatives became part of an archive created by the excavators, along with letters, plans, drawings and diaries. When Carter died in 1939, he bequeathed most of his estate to his niece, Phyllis Walker (1897–1977), including the archaeological records. Following the advice of Egyptologists Alan H. Gardiner (1879–1963) and Percy E. Newberry (1869–1949), who had both been on the team, Walker presented the documentation, with associated copyright, to the Griffith Institute, University of Oxford, in 1945. The physical archive remains in Oxford and can be freely explored online, allowing scholars from across the world to continually reassess the burial and its discovery (Rosenow, Parkinson 2022: 8).
To celebrate the 100th anniversary of the discovery of the tomb of Tutankhamun in November 1922, Griffith Institute staff, working with Bodleian Libraries staff, created the exhibition Tutankhamun: Excavating the Archive which can be seen at the Weston Library until 5 February 2023. (Fig. 2A). The accompanying publication (Fig. 2B) provides an overview of the archive, featuring 50 key items.
Fig. 2A: Tutankhamun: Excavating the Archive (Weston Library): Poster
Fig. 2B: Tutankhamun: Excavating the Archive (Weston Library): Exhibition catalogue
In conjunction with both anniversary and Weston Library exhibition, the current Tutankhamun book display at the Sackler Library (Oxford’s central repository for research publications on Egyptology) showcases a selection of works from its collections (Fig. 1). The items are organised into four thematic groups, with relevant new publications added throughout the duration of the display. Special features of this Sackler book display also include the facsimiles of two drawings by Carter; of Carter’s 1922 excavation diary in which he noted the discovery of the first step of an unknown tomb on 4 November; and of a photo album sold to tourists during the clearance of the tomb (Fig. 3).
Fig. 3: Items from the Howard Carter Archive (facsimiles). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
The publication group “The Excavation of Tutankhamun’s tomb and its finds” sets the scene with the authoritative work The tomb of Tut.ankh.Amen: discovered by the late Earl of Carnarvon and Howard Carter, published in three volumes between 1923 and 1933 by Howard Carter and Arthur Mace (1874-1928). The first volume, opened at page 96 (Fig. 4), features in the centre of the display: here, the reader will find the magic words ‘Yes, wonderful things’, supposedly uttered by Carter when glimpsing, through a small breach in the doorway into the Antechamber of the tomb, and making out, in the flickering light of a candle, golden beds in various animal shapes, exquisite furniture, alabaster vessels and food containers. The b/w photo (Plate XV, opposite page 96) captures Carter’s view. However, according to his Excavation Journal (26 November 1922), held in the Griffith Institute Archive, Carter replied ‘Yes, it is wonderful’, casting doubt on the precise wording of his comment (James 2006: 253); the Weston Library exhibition catalogue leans more towards the version given in the Excavation Journal, written close to the events (Parkinson 2022: 40-41) and not intended for the general public.
Fig. 4: ‘Yes, wonderful things’ (Carter, H., Mace, A. C. (1923): 96. Image credit: S. Woodhouse
When concerns regarding media access and the constant stream of visitors to the small tomb came to a head between Carter and the Egyptian Antiquities Service in February 1924, Carter and his team departed from the site mid-season, leaving behind the heavy coffin lid hanging from the scaffolding above the coffin. In a statement underpinned by documents for private circulation Carter sets forth his line of action. With only a few dozen copies printed, this historic document was reprinted and introduced by N. Reeves in 1998 (Fig. 5).
These events also feature in a then little-known publication, ‘Schlagzeile Tutenchamun’ in which the author retraces the general media coverage of the discovery of the tomb received in the world press, including in Germany (Fig. 6).
Fig. 5: Carter 1998. Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Fig. 6: Otto 2005. Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Fig. 7: The first catalogue of the Tutankhamun display at the Egyptian Museum, Cairo (Matḥaf al-Miṣrī 1926). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Once recorded by Carter and his team, the finds were crated and shipped to the Egyptian Museum in Cairo at the end of each excavation season, for immediate display. Curious travellers calling on Carter for a tour of the tomb were referred to the Tutankhamun collection at the Egyptian Museum. In 1926 the first catalogue of the permanently displayed objects was published (Fig. 7), serving interested visitors as a gallery guide. Future supplements of the catalogue were to include newly added objects.
Fig. 8: Drawing of the four sides of all four nested shrines which enclosed the coffin (Piankoff 1951-1952: pl. 22). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
The popular account ‘The tomb of Tut.ankh.Amen’ was Carter’s only monograph on this subject. Although he continued adding to the excavation files, the planned multi-volume work dedicated to the finds never materialised. Owning the publication rights, Carter was in a position to ask colleagues for help with this colossal task but it doesn’t seem he ever did. After his death in 1939 the rights, together with his papers, were transferred to his niece who subsequently deeded them to the Griffith Institute in 1945. Finally, in 1951 the first scholarly monograph, dedicated to one object group from the tomb, was published by Alexandre Piankoff, a specialist in religious texts.
In the introduction to ‘Les chapelles de Tout-Ankh-Amon’ (Fig. 8) the author recalls how during WWII the Director General of the Service des Antiquités de l’Égypte suggested he prepare a study of the texts on these four shrines, and how afterwards Oxford-based Alan Gardiner granted Piankoff the publication rights. An expanded English version was published in 1955 (Fig. 9).
Fig. 9: The second golden shrine (Piankoff 1955). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
In her extensive study of the iconic photographs produced by Harry Burton, Christina Riggs calls them ‘the most famous and compelling archaeological images ever made’ (Fig. 10). She describes the technical aspects of producing glass negatives and the difficult working conditions under which Burton took well over 3,000 shots.
Fig. 10: Harry Burton’s photo of Tutankhamun’ coffin being examined (Riggs 2019: fig. 7.1). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Sumptuous colour images of the objects were published in 2007 in the form of a coffee-table book, the product of a successful cooperation between the photographer Sandro Vannini and the Egyptologist Zahi Hawass (Fig. 11).
Once Carter’s papers and the publication rights were transferred to the Griffith Institute, Alan Gardiner worked tirelessly on having the tomb content published; this is the topic of the second thematic group on display: “Tutankhamun and Oxford”. The Griffith Institute did not have the financial means required for the multi-volume scholarly publication of the tomb finds (Fox 1951: Preface; Eaton-Krauss 2020: 17) and the outbreak of the Egyptian Revolution in 1952 put an end to Gardiner’s efforts to find the necessary funding in Egypt (James 2006: 445; Eaton-Krauss 2020: 217-218).
Fig. 11: Detail from Tutankhamun’s gilded throne (Hawass, Vannini 2007: 57). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Fig. 12: Fox 1951. Image credit: S. Woodhouse
In 1951 Oxford University Press published ‘Tutankhamun’s treasure’, written by the Griffith Institute’s Assistant Secretary Penelope Fox and highlighting various objects from the tomb (Fig. 12). Although this book was not the ultimate publication Alan Gardiner had in mind, it was the first monograph dedicated to the tomb’s finds produced in Oxford.
Eleven years later the Griffith Institute finally published its first object-focused study. ‘Tutankhamun’s painted box’ is the result of a collaboration between the preeminent copyist and illustrator Nina de Garis Davies (1881-1965), who painted facsimiles of all five decorated surfaces of the box, and Alan Gardiner, who wrote the introduction (Fig. 13).
Fig. 13: Panel of a box from the tomb of Tutankhamun, copied by Nina de Garis Davies (Davies, Gardiner 1962). Image credit: Griffith Institute
Finally, in 1963 the Griffith Institute’s Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series (Fig. 14) was launched and a total of nine monographs were published until 1990 when the series was discontinued (Eaton-Krauss 2020: 218-219). Since this date the Griffith Institute has published further definitive monographs on specific object groups from the tomb, though these are no longer part of a series.
Fig. 14: Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series (v. 9 was on loan at the time the image was taken). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Fig. 15: Catalogue for the Tutankhamun exhibition at the British Museum in 1972 (Edwards 1972b). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Titled “Tutankhamun and the British Museum” the third publication group on display centres on one of the most iconic exhibitions ever shown in the UK. With 1,602,000 visitors, it was the most successful exhibition at the British Museum to date. In 1972, after years of preparations and negotiations, the 50th anniversary of the discovery of the tomb was celebrated with a special exhibition at the British Museum; 50 objects from the tomb were on show, including the golden mask. The cover of the accompanying exhibition catalogue shows an intimate scene between the King and his Queen from a gilded shrine, framed in shades of orange and brown typical for the time (Fig. 15). In a contemporary BBC 4 documentary Magnus Magnusson introduced viewers to the exhibition. The proceeds from this — £600,000 (today’s value £7,6m) — helped pay for the rescue of the temples at Philae (Edwards 1972a: 10; Zaki 2017: 86).
In 1992, the 70th anniversary of the tomb’s discovery, the British Museum showcased Howard Carter’s 30 years of work in Egypt prior to 1922. The exhibition was an academic and popular success (Fig. 16).
Fig. 16: Catalogue for the Tutankhamun exhibition at the British Museum in 1992 (Reeves, Taylor 1992). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Fig. 17: James 2006. Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Having known families of colleagues as well as close contacts of Carter and having been granted unique access to their papers, T.G.H. James (1923-2009), Deputy Keeper of the Egyptian Department at the British Museum at the time of the 1972 blockbuster, wrote an authoritative biography on Carter (James 2006: Fig. 17). This publication was followed by a lavishly illustrated book in which he discusses objects from the tomb (James 2007).
Aspects addressed in the fourth thematic group on display, “Reception of Tutankhamun”, are Egyptomania (Fig. 18), literature, Egypt’s nationalist movement, and tourism in Egypt in the wake of the discovery of the tomb.
Fig. 18: A Cartier brooch inspired by Tutankhamun’s head, shown emerging from a lotus flower (Humbert, Pantazzi, Ziegler 1994: cat. No. 366). Image credit: S. Woodhouse
Susanne Woodhouse Subject Librarian for Egyptology and Ancient Near Eastern Studies Bodleian Libraries
With the assistance of Jenna Ilett Graduate Library Trainee
Bodleian Libraries
Eaton-Krauss, M. (2020) ‘Publications in monographic form of the ‘treasure’ of Tutankhamun, 1952-2020′, Göttinger Miszellen, 262, pp. 217-225.
Eaton-Krauss, M. (2014) ‘Impact of the discovery of KV62 (The Tomb of Tutankhamun)’, KMT, 25.1, pp. 29-37.
Rosenow, D. and Parkinson, R.B. (2022) ‘Tutankhamun: The Oxford Archive’, Scribe. The American Research Center in Egypt, 58, 8–11.
Zaki, A. A. (2017) ‘Tutankhamun Exhibition at the British Museum in 1972: a historical perspective’, Journal of Tourism Theory and Research, 3(2), 2017, 80-88. DOI: 10.24288/jttr.312180
Displayed books
Baines, J. and el-Khouli, A. (1993) Stone vessels, pottery and sealings from the tomb of Tutʿankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute, Ashmolean Museum.
Beinlich, H., Saleh, M. and Murray, H. (1989) Corpus der hieroglyphischen Inschriften aus dem Grab des Tutanchamun : mit Konkordanz der Nummernsysteme des “Journal d’Entrée” des Ägyptischen Museums Kairo, der Handlist to Howard Carter’s catalogue of objects in Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb und der Ausstell. Oxford: Griffith Institute, Ashmolean Museum.
Broschat, K. and Schutz, M. (2021) Iron from Tutankhamun’s tomb. Cairo: American University in Cairo Press.
Carter, H. (1998) Tut·ankh·amen : the politics of discovery. London: Libri.
Carter, H. and Mace, A.C. (1923-1933) The tomb of Tut.ankh.Amen discovered by the late Earl of Carnarvon and Howard Carter. 3 vols. London ; New York: Cassell.
Černý, J. (1965) Hieratic inscriptions from the tomb of Tutʿankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 2).
Colla, E. (2007) Conflicted antiquities : Egyptology, Egyptomania, Egyptian modernity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Collins, P. and McNamara, L. (2014) Discovering Tutankhamun. Oxford: Ashmolean Museum.
Davies, N.M. and Gardiner, A.H. (1962) Tutankhamun’s painted box : reproduced in colour from the original in the Cairo Museum. Oxford: Griffith Institute.
Dobson, E. (2020) Writing the Sphinx : literature, culture and Egyptology. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press (Edinburgh critical studies in Victorian culture).
Eaton-Krauss, M. and Graefe, E. (1985) The small golden shrine from the tomb of Tutankhamun. Oxford : Atlantic Highlands, N.J: Griffith Institute ; Distributed in the U.S.A. by Humanities Press.
Eaton-Krauss, M. (1993) The sarcophagus in the tomb of Tutankhamun. Oxford: Griffith Institute, Ashmolean Museum.
Eaton-Krauss, M. and Segal, W. (2008) The thrones, chairs, stools, and footstools from the tomb of Tutankhamun. Oxford: Griffith Institute.
Edwards, I.E.S. (1972a) ‘The Tutankhamun exhibition’, British Museum Society Bulletin, 9, pp. 7-11.
Edwards, I.E.S. (1972b) Treasures of Tutankhamun. London: British Museum.
Fox, P. (1951) Tutankhamun’s treasure. London ; New York: Oxford University Press.
Gabolde, M. (2015) Toutankhamon. Paris: Pygmalion (Grands pharaons).
Germer, R. (1989) Die Pflanzenmaterialien aus dem Grab des Tutanchamun. Hildesheim: Gerstenberg (Hildesheimer ägyptologische Beiträge ; 28).
Haas Dantes, F. (2022) Transformation eines Königs : eine Analyse der Ausstattung von Tutanchamuns Mumie. S.l.: SCHWABE AG.
Hawass, Z.A. and Vannini, S. (2007) King Tutankhamun : the treasures of the tomb. London: Thames & Hudson.
Hepper, F.N. (2009) Pharaoh’s flowers : the botanical treasures of Tutankhamun. 2nd edn. Chicago ; London: KWS Pub.
Humbert, J.-M (2022) Art déco : Égyptomanie. Paris: Norma Éditions
Humbert, J.-M., Pantazzi, M. and Ziegler, C. (1994) Egyptomania : l’Égypte dans l’art occidental, 1730-1930. Paris: Réunion des musées nationaux.
James, T.G.H. (2006) Howard Carter : the path to Tutankhamun. Rev, pbk. London: Taurus Parke Paperbacks.
James, T.G.H. (2007) Tutankhamun : the eternal splendor of the boy pharaoh. Rev. Vercelli: White Star.
Jones, D. (1990) Model boats from the tomb of Tuʿtankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 9).
Leek, F.F. (1972) The human remains from the tomb of Tutʿankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 5).
Littauer, M.A. and Crouwel, J.H. (1985) Chariots and related equipment from the tomb of Tut’ankhamūn. Oxford : Atlantic Highlands, N.J: Griffith Institute ; Distributed in the U.S.A. by Humanities Press (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 8).
Málek, J. (2007) Tutankhamun : the secrets of the tomb and the life of the Pharaohs. London: Carlton.
Manniche, L. (1976) Musical instruments from the tomb of Tut’ankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 6).
Manniche, L. (2019) The ornamental calcite vessels from the tomb of Tutankhamun. Leuven: Peeters (Griffith Institute publications).
Matḥaf al-Miṣrī (1926) A short description of the objects from the tomb of Tutankhamum now exhibited in the Cairo Museum. [Cairo: Egyptian Museum].
McLeod, W. (1970) Composite bows from the tomb of Tut’ankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 3).
McLeod, W. (1982) Self bows and other archery tackle from the tomb of Tutʿankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 4).
Murray, H. and Nuttall, M. (1963) A handlist to Howard Carter’s catalogue of objects in Tutʿankhamūn’s tomb. Oxford: Printed for the Griffith Institute at the University Press by V. Ridler (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 1).
Otto, A. (2005) Schlagzeile Tutenchamun : die publizistische Begleitung der Entdeckung und der Ausräumung des Grabes von Tutenchamun. Marburg: Tectum.
Piankoff, A. (1951-1952) Les chapelles de Tout-Ankh-Amon. Le Caire: Impr. de l’Institut français d’archéologie orientale (Mémoires publiés par les membres de l’Institut français d’archéologie orientale du Caire ; t.72).
Piankoff, A. and Rambova, N. (1955) The shrines of Tut-Ankh-Amon. New York: Pantheon Books (Bollingen Series ; 40:2).
Quaegebeur, J. and Cherpion, N. (1999) La naine et le bouquetin : ou l’énigme de la barque en albâtre de Toutankhamon. Leuven: Peeters.
Reeves, N. (1990) The complete Tutankhamun : the king, the tomb, the royal treasure. London: Thames and Hudson.
Reeves, N. and Taylor, J.H. (1992) Howard Carter before Tutankhamun. London: British Museum Press for the Trustees of the British Museum.
Reid, D.M. (2015) Contesting antiquity in Egypt : archaeologies, museums & the struggle for identities from World War I to Nasser. Cairo: American University in Cairo Press.
Riggs, C. and Wace, R. (2017) Tutankhamun : the original photographs. London: Rupert Wace Ancient Art.
Riggs, C. (2019) Photographing Tutankhamun : archaeology, ancient Egypt, and the archive. London: Bloomsbury Visual Arts (Photography, history: history, photography).
Riggs, C. (2021) Treasured : how Tutankhamun shaped a century. London: Atlantic Books.
Tait, W.J. (1982) Game-boxes and accessories from the tomb of Tutʿankhamūn. Oxford: Griffith Institute (Tutʿankhamūn’s Tomb Series ; 7).
Vartavan, C.de. and Boodle, L.A. (1999) Hidden fields of Tutankhamun : from identification to interpretation of newly discovered plant material from the Pharaoh’s grave. London: Triade Exploration (Triade Exploration’s opus magnum series in the field of Egyptology ; 2).
Veldmeijer, A.J. (2010) Tutankhamun’s footwear : studies of ancient Egyptian footwear. Norg, Netherlands: Drukware.
Vogelsang-Eastwood, G., Hense, M. and Wilson, K. (1999) Tutankhamun’s wardrobe : garments from the tomb of Tutankhamun. Rotterdam: Barjesteh van Waalwijk van Doorn & Co’s.
Wilkinson, T. (2022) Tutankhamun’s trumpet : the story of ancient Egypt in 100 objects. London: Picador.
Ukraine Independence Day at the Sackler Library Book Display
By Jamie Copeland
The Sackler Library has hosted a display celebrating the unique cultural heritage of Ukraine since the start of the Russian invasion back in February (see below for one such iteration).
A previous version of the Sackler Library’s Ukraine book display
Although the display was curated and regularly updated (by Graduate Library Trainee Izzie Salter, during her traineeship) it was felt that something new should be created; both to mark Ukraine Independence Day and to do what the Libraries could to promote an awareness of Ukraine’s artistic, archaeological and architectural heritage. There was also the opportunity to display the breadth of the Sackler’s collections, stretching from archaeological findings, including Scythian jewellery, through the Golden Age of Kyiv and the treasures of the churches, up to the strife of recent centuries and events where avant-garde and contemporary artists have continued the varieties of a resilient Ukrainian culture.
As the deadline of Ukraine Independence Day was close, I wanted to focus largely on the Sackler’s collections as they were immediately accessible (compared to the items held in other libraries) and could be selected for visual impact and as part of a curated collection focusing on material culture. I also wanted to take the opportunity to highlight individual artists who I felt had made important contributions to Ukraine’s culture. One of the more interesting issues of the conflict was also the debate about what constituted an independent Ukraine and whether there was such a nationality as the Ukrainians; from the history of nomadic populations and disputed borders to the internationalism of the USSR, masking famines and deportations. By promoting individual artists, I felt I could examine the histories of people such as Kazimir Malevich, an ethnically Polish artist born in Kiev, highly regarded as a leading figure in the Soviet avant-garde who described his nationality as Ukrainian when arrested for crimes against ‘Socialist Realism’. Another figure I found to be of interest was Donia Naschen, born in Zhitomir (then Russia, now Ukraine) whose family fled tsarist pogroms to settle in London, illustrating editions of Gogol, translations of the Haggadah, and WWII propaganda posters. I wanted to take the opportunity to highlight such individuals, from various backgrounds, linked by war and exile, but marked, I felt, by the shared environment of Ukraine and its cultures.
It was also necessary to create a poster to publicize the display. While researching the artists I had seen a particular work by Malevich which, unlike his more abstract works, shows a figure, almost devoid of feature, standing against a background that closely matches the Ukraine flag. Although the figure is faceless it seemed that this made it more representative of a people, with its seeming motionless, expressing an air of steadfastness.
Poster image: Kazimir Malevich. Sensation of an imprisoned man (1930-31)
While reading about the painting technique used by Malevich, the building of layers of paint to achieve a unique colour through the accumulation of surfaces, it occurred to me that I could add a (digital) layer of yellow to the image to heighten the resemblance to the flag without completely effacing the underlying image. I felt that this could be symbolic of the various histories of Ukraine and work as a promotional poster for the display, which I intended to reflect the Sackler’s holdings on Ukraine’s culture, celebrating its Independence Day, while extending beyond the war. The alterations to the image were made with GIMP, using largely fill and brush effects to retain a paint resemblance and allow the original image to show through. This was then pasted into a Word document to enable revisions to the text of the poster to be easily made.
With the art, archaeology and architecture collections that would make up the display, I wanted to include some books, such as ‘The gates of Europe: a history of Ukraine’ that would give an accessible overview of the nation’s history, combined with books, preferably in one of the languages previously/currently used in Ukraine, and from the Sackler holdings, that could address more specific topics. I wanted these, as being largely textual, to be arranged in a stack similar to a bookshop display to encourage people to feel free to browse the volumes without feeling that they were tampering with an arranged display.
To complement this and to reflect the strengths of the Sackler Library collections in architecture, archaeology and art I decided to group books in an order that would broadly follow the layout of the collections around the Sackler’s five-floor building. (See below image galleries.) So, starting from the left-hand side of the display, with items from the archaeology collections (normally housed on the Library’s lower floors) forming a pillar surmounted by a striking visual image. Complementing this, I placed a German language book on the early history of the Crimea, choosing a map showing the Scythians’ movement through the Crimea, which I hoped would display the long history of migration while showing Ukraine and the currently annexed Crimea as deeply connected geographies. The facing page also had illustrations of archaeological finds, which I wanted as a demonstration of the scientific aspect of that collection. While arranging the display I became concerned that a prominent map of an invasion might not be suitable for a day celebrating that nation’s independence. To balance this, I placed a book showing the collection of the Lviv Picture Gallery, open at a page containing a portrait of a woman dressed in blue and yellow.
Echoing this, and shifting to the Sackler Library’s art collections, I placed a selection of books on individual artists in the space behind, with the book, ‘Alexis Gritchenko: Dynamocolor’ opened at a painting that again had strong use of yellow and blue facing the chapter title quotation ‘The Young Ukrainian Artist Has Conquered Paris’ which I felt demonstrated the importance of Ukraine’s contribution to global culture and refuted the claim that Ukraine was merely a Russian province whose sense of nationhood was a recent Western creation.
To support the poster, I placed a book with Malevich’s name clearly visible. Although the Sackler has impressive holdings of publications on this artist I was careful about keeping the focus upon Ukraine Independence Day, so I restricted myself to one book on Malevich and one book about the Anna Leporskaya collection of his work, as she was an important Ukraine artist in her own right. I also felt her work as an archivist indicated the importance of cultural institutions as collective memory-banks. Below this, I placed a copy of the Haggadah, open at Donia Naschen’s illustration of Israel’s bondage, as I felt this would be a recognisable scene and that the yellow matched the adjacent promotion of badges supporting Ukraine.
Ukraine badges
(Please collect your Ukraine badge from the display.)
Finally, I placed another group of books themed around religious art and church buildings, as this would represent the Sackler’s holdings on architecture, and the significance of the granting of autocephaly to the Orthodox Church of Ukraine in 2019, described by the then president as ‘a charter of [Ukraine’s] spiritual independence’.
Although reasonably happy with the final arrangement of the display, I was conscious of the need to show traditionally underrepresented artists and cultures within the Ukraine spectrum. Although work on these categories has been published recently, many of these publications are available primarily online so I was unable to include them in the display. I also wanted to make better use of the Sackler’s collections of art journals, especially regarding more contemporary artists. As the plan is to update the display in coming weeks I hope to be able to include this material in future arrangements.
Dante Alighieri. The Divine Comedy. Translated by T.G. Bergin. Illustrated by Leonard Baskin (New York: Grossman, 1969)
This blog post documents my experience as a Graduate Library Trainee assisting at the ‘Introduction to Bodleian Libraries Special Collections’ event, held for History of Art undergraduate and graduate students at the Taylor Institution Library in December 2021.
Setting up for the Bodleian Libraries Special Collections event held for History of Art students at the Taylor Institution Library, December 2021. In the foreground: Edgar Allan Poe. The Raven. Illustrated by Mario Prassinos. (Paris: P. Vorms, 1952)
Across the libraries, we hold a myriad of intriguing and unique items. Still, it may be difficult for readers to know how to find these, and where to start. It is here where the then Subject Librarian for Art & Architecture Librarian and Italian Literature & Language, Clare Hills-Nova, was able to draw upon her knowledge of the Bodleian Libraries’ collections to introduce History of Art students to a few of our less well-known holdings.
Since having arrived at the Sackler in September 2021, I have been fortunate to spend plenty of time around visual culture materials. I’ve arranged a Japanese photobook display (in support of the Ashmolean’s Tokyo! exhibition), relabelled items from the WJ Strachan collection, and processed new publications about architects and artists on a broad range of periods and geographic areas. This is a far cry from my undergraduate haunts of law statutes and case reports – albeit a very welcome change. When Clare asked me to support the event she was planning for the History of Art Department’s students, and subsequently attend it, I was more than happy.
Artist interpretations of Dante’s Divine Comedy (14th Century – 21st Century)
The event comprised two parts. The first, held in the Voltaire Room, expanded upon the Taylorian’s exhibition on Dante Alighieri and his Divine Comedy, which my fellow Trainee Malcolm Spencer has so wonderfully discussed. The exhibition’s curator, Professor Gervase Rosser led a presentation here – titled ‘Illustrating Dante’s Divine Comedy – on artists’ interpretations of the themes expressed in the Comedy.
‘Illustrating Dante’s Divine Comedy’. Exhibition installation: One of the display cases in the Voltaire Room, Taylor Institution Library, showcasing work inspired by Dante’s The Divine Comedy. (Artists represented: Federico Zuccari, Giovanni Stradano, John Flaxman and Leonard Baskin.) Credit: Malcolm Spencer
This incorporated a vast range of work and approaches, as Professor Rosser traced the fluctuating reception of Dante’s Divine Comedy through the centuries. The talk (and display) included: a facsimile of one of the earliest illustrated Dante manuscripts of the 1330s; an edition of Doré’s seminal engravings, through which he became considered a ‘master of the visually dramatic narrative’ (Angel, 2014) (see image below, line 2, tile 1); and American artist Leonard Baskin’s compelling illustrations (1969). Also on view were some of the many recent translations of the Divine Comedy — some of them with striking book covers and other illustrative material.
A selection of translations of and commentaries on Dante’s Divine Comedy, from 1544 to 2018, shown at the event.
Edouard Goerg. L’Enfer [Dante’s Hell] (Paris: J. Porson, 1950)
In advance of this, Malcolm and I gathered together items on artists’ engagement with Dante from our libraries.
Among these were a small publication illustrating Geoffrey MacEwan’s paintings, Edouard Goerg’s etchings for Dante’s L’Enfer (Hell), many new translations with images of the Divine Comedy, and the Uffizi’s recent exhibition catalogue, Dante: la visione dell’arte, documenting many of the countless works inspired by Dante and the rest of his literary oeuvre. Books additional to those already on view in the exhibition’s display cases were arranged carefully around the room, framing the exhibition.
Athanasius Kircher’s L’Arca di Noë (Amsterdam, 1675)
Athanasius Kircher. L’Arca di Noë (Amsterdam, 1975)
The second part of the event took place in the Taylorian’s Room 2, and showcased other works from the Sackler, Taylorian and Weston Libraries’ Special Collections. These works ranged in date and publication location from 17th century Amsterdam to 1970s Tokyo, via 1960s Los Angeles. Here, the earliest work on display was Athanasius Kircher’s (1602-1680)L’Arca di Noë (Amsterdam, 1675). This publication includes, for example, as shown, Kircher’s illustrations of hieroglyphics. Kircher prolifically studied and attempted to decipher Egyptian hieroglyphics – from his translations and commentaries, he became considered ‘one of the greatest polymaths in 17th-Century Europe’ (Klawitter, 2015).
The page on display at the event was a fold-out depiction of the interior of Noah’s Ark, showing Noah’s family members, barrels of food (or beer) and a menagerie of creatures. What struck me in this view was the measurements below the image, giving dimensions of the Ark itself. Beyond being a fascinating detail, this grounds the narrative in reality. For contemporaries, it made the Ark easier to conceive, and its magnificent nature – even including a pair of unicorns – that bit more believable.
Athanasius Kircher. L’Arca di Noë (1675) [composite image of several photos, from a fold-out page in the book, pasted together]
Up close: beer barrels and unicorns; measurements of the Ark.
F.G. Haverfield Collection (18th century interpretations of Classical art)
Turning to 18th century England, students could also see examples from the Sackler’s F. J. Haverfield Archive — specifically, from his collection of images of Romano-British pavement mosaics. On display was an illustration of themosaic found at Littlecote Park, Wiltshire – the ‘Orpheus’ mosaic – alongside Joseph Bonomi’s (1739-1808) original carpet and ceiling designs (1785) for Bowood House, Wiltshire. Bonomi, like many of his contemporaries such as the Adam brothers – John (1721-1792), Robert (1728-1792), and James (1732- 1794) – for whom he worked at various points, was inspired by classical art and architecture. It is thought that Haverfield may have included the Bonomi designs in his image collection because one of their sources of inspiration could have been the mosaics discovered around this time. Indeed, the carpet bears some resemblance in shape and content to the mosaic (and is perhaps why Haverfield included it in his collection). You can find more about these works in a blog post written by former Trainee, Chloe Bolsover. These parallels were instantly compelling. The students could see the physical copies displayed side-by-side, draw comparisons, and possibly gain an understanding of the thought processes underlying Haverfield’s collection.
Joseph Bonomi. Carpet and Centaur Ceiling designs for Bowood House, Wiltshire (1785); George Vertue. A Roman mosaic found at Littlecote Park (1730)
W.J. Strachan Collection (mid-20th Century)
In the weeks preceding the event, Clare and I had explored the Strachan Collection of mid-20th century artists’ books, made in France, for potential display items. The Strachan Collection comprises over 250 items – with, according to Strachan himself, ‘every ‘ism” from Cubism to neo-realism represented. Therefore, deciding which items to include for the event was a challenge.
William Shakespeare. La Tempête. Illustrated by Leonor Fini (Paris: Aux dépens d’un amateur, 1965)
Ultimately, we decided to focus primarily on women, non-French and other less well-known artists. Among the selection was Leonor Fini’s beautiful lithographs for Shakespeare’s La Tempête (The Tempest), and Chinese artist Zao Wou-ki’s lithographs illustrating André Malraux’s La Tentation del’Occident. To me, Wou-ki’s work was especially well-suited for the ‘Show’ aspect of this event: his bright and gestural work seems to capture harsh emotions so succinctly: hard to miss.
Andre Malraux. La Tentation de l’Occident. Illustrated by Zao Wou-ki (Paris: Les Bibliophiles Comptois, 1962) [Lower left corner: Le livre d’artiste: A Catalogue of the W.J. Strachan gift to the Taylor Institution (Oxford: Ashmolean Museum & Taylor Institution, 1987)]
Hans Bellmer, a German artist, was also on display. Bellmer is best known for creating a series of life-sized dolls and photographing them. The Nazi Party labelled this work as ‘degenerate’, causing him to flee to France in 1938, where he remained for the rest of his life. His interest in dolls can be seen in his engravings for Les Marionettes, through the somewhat disjointed limbs he illustrated. These are coloured with a distinct blue and yellow. For me, this made Bellmer’s work particularly effective for a Show-and-Tell: viewers can trace the lines of his drawings, and enjoy the unique colours against the brown paper.
Heinrich von Kleist. Les Marionettes. Illustrated by Hans Bellmer (Paris: G. Visat, 1970)
Alongside these artists from the Strachan collection was Wifredo Lam’s etchings for L’antichambre de la Nature. Of Chinese and Afro-Cuban descent Lam became familiar with African spiritual rites. It was also at this point that he began to be influenced by Surrealism. In 1938, he moved to Paris and met members of the art and poetry scene. He began to work alongside Picasso and became more interested by Cubism. After the Nazis occupied Paris, Lam returned to Cuba. Here, he combined his multiple artistic influences with his cultural experiences to create works on Afro-Cuban identity. To me, these various influences make Lam’s work so unique and striking. His singular work was therefore very fitting for the event, both to look at and to appreciate the diversity of the 1930s Parisian art scene.
Alain Jouffroy. L’antichambre de la Nature. Illustrated by Wifredo Lam (Paris: O. Lazar-Vernet, 1960)
Ed Ruscha’s Every Building on the Sunset Strip (1966)
Edward Ruscha. Every Building on the Sunset Strip (Los Angeles, 1966)
Students viewing Edward Ruscha. Every Building on the Sunset Strip (Los Angeles, 1966)
We also showed Edward (Ed) Ruscha’s iconic Every Building on the Sunset Strip (1966). Running through through West Hollywood, Ruscha pasted hundreds of his photographs of the Strip together to create an 8-metre linear image. He shot these photos from his pick-up truck, with a motorized Nikon camera positioned on top. Interestingly, Ruscha opted to set the lens to infinity, bringing everything in each image into equal focus. The result is remarkable, almost like a flattened montage. Every Building on the Sunset Strip arrived in a slim silver slipcase – deceptively, very small (18 cm.). As we unfolded it, we asked our building staff, again and again, to bring in another table to support the length of the ‘strip’. It ended up stretching almost the whole length of the Taylorian’s Room 2! In the images shown here, the viewer can grasp the extent of the Strip, as Ruscha perhaps intended it to be viewed (many museums display it in concertina format).
Edward Ruscha. Every Building on the Sunset Strip (1966)
The Japanese Box (1960s-1970s)
The item I was personally most excited about was The Japanese Box, a facsimile edition (2001) of seminal photographic works produced in post-War Japan. Throughout this Michaelmas term 2021 at the Sackler Library, I worked with a lot of material on Japanese photography, particularly from the 1970s. I created a book display in conjunction with the Tokyo exhibition at the Ashmolean Museum, and a corresponding blog post. Whilst researching for the post, I read a lot about Provoke, a 1960s-1970s avant-garde Japanese photography magazine, and its associated photographers. I developed a real love for the style and telos of this magazine. The photographers tasked themselves with reclaiming ‘documentation’ and they were keen to show life in 1970s Japan beyond the general perception of it as an economic powerhouse and post-war ideal. When Clare told me that the event for the History of Art students would include a box of recently-acquired facsimiles of the three issues of Provoke, alongside monographs by Provoke photographers,I was genuinely thrilled.
The Japanese Box: Provoke issues 1, 2 and 3; Takuma Nakahira. Kitarubeki kotoba no tame ni (For a language to come) (1970); Nobuyoshi Araki. Senchimentaru na tabi (Sentimental journey) (1971); and Daido Moriyama. Shashin yo sayonara (A farewell to photography) (1972)
The Japanese Box : Facsimile Reprint of Six Rare Photographic Publications of the Provoke Era. Designed by Karl Lagerfeld.(Limited ed. Paris, 2001)
As with much of Japanese publishing it was clear that a lot of thought had gone into the design and packaging of this facsimile set. Characteristically, the black box containing the publications was itself striking: it was designed by Karl Lagerfeld. Inside, ‘designer’ plastic bands, labelled ‘The Japanese Box’, carefully held the six publications together. We spread them out on the table, ready for students to examine. Picking each volume up, we could see a rich array of photos of Japan and each artist’s personal experience of living there. This ranged from Nobuyoshi Araki’s photos of his honeymoon in Sentimental Journey (Senchimentaru na tabi), to student protests in Tokyo in Provoke. A few days ahead of the event, Clare asked me to introduce the event’s attendees to the box and its contents. Studying and presenting this set was a highlight of my traineeship. After my presentation several students asked to examine the Box’s contents further, and we discussed the Provoke movement while viewing our favourite images in the set.
Concluding thoughts
At the event itself, the students appeared to be completely immersed in the works we showed. In the Voltaire Room, where Professor Gervase Rosser presented the Dante-inspired work, attendees asked questions about how different artists interpreted the themes of the Divine Comedy. In Room 2, the group lined up along the length of Every Building on the Sunset Strip, pointing at (for example) where pasted pictures cut up cars. L’Arca di Noë invited students to examine the interplay between imagination and reality,whilst others admired the various artists’ books and different mosaic patterns from the Haverfield collection. Although held on the last day of term, the event overran, with many attendees keen to continue examining and discussing the works on display. It was a huge success, and a tribute to the remarkable range of Special Collections held across the libraries. I cannot wait to explore them further.
Izzie Salter Graduate Trainee, Sackler Library
References
Angel, Sara. “‘Too Many Illustrations, Not Enough Glory’: Known for his Art for Dante’s ‘Inferno,’ Gustave Dore Merited Wider Fame.” Maclean’s (Toronto) 127.23 (2014): 66. Web. (available publicly here)
Strachan, WJ. The Artist and the Book in France. The 20th Century Livre D’artiste. London: Owen, 1969. Print. (Sackler Library Shelfmark: 914.2 Str)
By Dr Rebecca Bowen (Retained Lecturer in Italian, Pembroke College)
Illustrating Dante’s Divine Comedy. Exhibition view, Voltaire Room, Taylor Institution Library (October – December 2021)
2021 marked the 700th anniversary of the death of Dante Alighieri, Florentine poet, author of the Divine Comedy, and an icon of medieval European literature. The many celebrations held in his honour ranged from exhibitions, rare book displays and academic conferences to live readings of the poem and even Dante-themed ice-creams. This cultural eclecticism attests to the enduring impact of Dante’s works as well as the celebrity of his image, an image able to be absorbed into gastronomic promotions as much as lauded for its literary might. The distorting effects of fame were a preoccupation of Dante who, at the start of his philosophical treatise the Convivio, complains: ‘I have appeared before the eyes of many who, perhaps because of some report (fama), had imagined me in another light […since] the image generated by fame alone is always greater, whatever it may be, than the imagined thing in its true state’ (Convivio. I.iii.11).
Uncovering the ‘true state’ of Dante and his works is a primary aim of Dante Studies, an area of research that has thrived at Oxford since the late 19th century. The University’s museums and libraries have always played a crucial role in this path of discovery, preserving rich records of the poet’s reception and the ongoing vitality of his readerly appeal. The recent exhibition of items from the Sackler and Taylor Institution libraries, ‘Illustrating Dante’s Divine Comedy’, was exemplary in this respect. Curated by Professor Gervase Rosser and Clare Hills-Nova with items from Bodleian Libraries collections (principally, Sackler Library and Taylor Institution Library), the display reflected the depth and eclecticism of the visual tradition held by the University, from the intricately illuminated pages of fourteenth-century manuscripts to the neo-expressionist lithographs produced by contemporary artist Mimmo Paladino of the recent centenary year.
Presided over by the Taylorian’s august bust of Dante, whose personal iconography is a topic of myth and debate, the exhibition showcased an array of colourful interpretations of the Comedy. What the poet himself might have made of this visual afterlife becomes an almost unavoidable area of speculation. In an apocryphal tale from the 1390s, the Florentine writer Franco Sacchetti imagines Dante vociferously defending his poem against misquotation by a blacksmith, exclaiming ‘I have no other craft, and you’re ruining it’ (Trecentonovelle, 114). As far as craft goes, the Comedy is very much a literary artefact, addressing its reader no less than fifteen times and frequently emphasising the ineffability of its own descriptions. What is a reader of Dante’s poem to make of visual renditions of his text?
Final year Italian Literature and Languages students from Pembroke, Merton and Wadham colleges turned their attention to this question, using their knowledge of Dante’s poem to examine the rich visual traditions on display in the Taylorian exhibition. Offering insights into the material history and visual details of some of the objects on display, Izzy, Joshua, Anna, Matt and Olivia explore the role of these illustrations as creative records of the poem’s reception, and offer reflections on why they are interested in reading Dante today.
19th and 20th century illustrations showing works by John Flaxman (lower left), Giovanni Stradano (upper right), and Federico Zuccari (upper left)
Isobel Sanders (Merton College)
Milton Klonsky. Blake’s Dante: The Complete Illustrations to the Divine Comedy (New York: Harmony, 1980).
Klomsky presents Blake’s evocative set of drawings and engravings for Dante’s Comedy, commissioned by John Linnell who sought to provide inspiration for Blake’s creativity alongside some much-needed money towards the end of his life. Few are complete yet this doesn’t make the rest any less engaging. Rather, we are granted insight into Blake’s artistic process, imagining for ourselves what a ‘completed, coloured-in’ version might look like. The works hug the text closely, although Blake didn’t always agree with Dante’s politics, revealed through damning remarks to friends. Small deviations appear in his watercolours, too. The Angel at Purgatory’s entrance seems bored or miserable, his eyelids half-shut; in Blake’s representation of Inferno 14, fire burns upwards rather than falling downwards. Could this be an act of defiance against Dante’s choice of infernal punishment known as the contrapasso, whereby sinners experienced a form of retribution directly related to their sin, often in inverse form? Politics, theology, ideas about fortune and sexuality all add nuance to Blake’s paintings. For, after all, going from one art form to another can never enact an exact ‘translation’. Blake’s illustrations, while rooted in the Romantic era, conjure up the Renaissance – the faces have a touch of Botticelli, or perhaps da Vinci, about them. Imaginative, unsettling and profoundly beautiful, Blake’s drawings establish a dialogue not only with Dante but also with other illustrators, over borders and across centuries. A perusal of Klomsky’s book reveals just how re-presenting the work of another is itself an exegesis – an act of personal interpretation and subsequent production.
Joshua Lavorini (Pembroke College)
Dante Alighieri. Opere di Dante Alighieri: Dedicata alla sagra imperial maesta di Elisabetta Petrowna, imperatrice di tutte le Russie ec. ec. ec. dal conte Don Cristoforo Zapata de Cisneros. Illustrated by Francesco Fontebasso, Gaetano Zompini & others 1757)
This image shows Dante presenting his work to the doge of Venice. The regal stature of the doge may call to mind the exile Dante suffered during the last twenty years of his life, since he learned ‘the bitterness of foreign bread’ (‘come sa di sale / lo pane altrui,’ Par. XVII.58–59) and was always both privileged and humbled by the patronage of other courts. The position of the crown above the doge’s head may be significant: in Paradiso, Dante fantasises that one day ‘I will return a poet, and at the font where I was baptised I will take the crown’ (‘ritorneró poeta, e in sul fonte / del mio battesmo prenderó ‘l cappello,’ Par. XXV.8–9) but in this image, it is the doge, to whom the poet comes in humility, that wears the crown. The faces in the crowd also provoke some thought – why do those to the right seem to be looking upwards towards the sky? What are those on the left looking at? Only the doge seems to be looking directly at the Tuscan poet. The dedication of this edition to Elizabeth Petrovna, Empress of Russia from 1741 until her death in 1762, attests to the fact that that Dante’s presence in Russia grew in the eighteenth century. Boris Antonov tells us that Petrovna encouraged Ivan Shuvalov’s foundation of the Imperial Academy of Arts and financed the grandiose Baroque projects of her favourite architect, Bartolomeo Rastrelli, particularly in the Peterhof Palace. She was clearly very interested in the arts (she spoke French, Italian and German as well as Russian), so it should come as no surprise that she should be fond of Dante. Dante’s impact on Russian culture continued long after her death, leaving a mark on the nation’s poetic symbolism. One Russian writer who was deeply interested in Italy and, by extension, Dante, is Nikolai Gogol. His book Dead Souls, described by him as a poem (despite being written in prose form), was intended to be the first part, i.e., Inferno, (set in contemporary Russia) of his own Divine Comedy. Gogol died before finishing the trilogy, and in a Virgilian act of insanity, burned the second part of Dead Souls. As well as his imitation of classical precedents (he wanted to imitate the Odyssey and Homeric epics), Gogol shares with Dante the use of almost uncomfortable humour and criticism of corruption. Another Russian whose work includes reference to Dante is Tchaikovsky. His orchestral fantasia Francesca da Rimini, Op. 32 (1876) was inspired by an episode in Canto V of the Inferno. In his correspondence, Tchaikovsky frequently quoted lines from Inferno V ‘there is no greater sorrow than to recall moments of happiness in misery’ (‘Nessun maggior dolore / che ricordarsi del tempo felice / ne la miseria,’ Inf. V.121–23), drawing on the enduring pathos of Dante’s infernal lovers.
Top Left: Landino’s and Vellutello’s combined commentary. Lower Right: Edition dedicated to Elisabetta Petrowna
Anna Zakonyi (Pembroke College)
Dante Alighieri, Cristoforo Landino, Alessandro Vellutello, La Comedia di Dante con l’espositione di Christoforo Landino, et di Alessandro Vellutello (Venice: Giovambattista Marchio Sessa et fratelli, 1564).
Landino and Vellutello’s combined commentary on Dante’s Divina Commedia was originally published in 1564 by the Venetian typographer Sessa, under the editorial supervision of Francesco Sansovino. Consisting of 28 introductory leaves and 392 leaves of commentary, this volume returns to the folio format of medieval tradition, incorporating woodcut illustrations from Marcolini’s Commedia (1544) and the two commentaries with citations of Dante’s poem. The illustrations, in contrast to previous iconographic tradition, act as a continuation of the commentaries, focusing particularly on the topography of Dante’s Afterlife. The combination of Landino and Vellutello’s commentaries on the Commedia (originally published in 1481 and 1544 respectively) is also novel, as it integrates two different approaches: Landino prioritises allegory whilst Vellutello focuses on meaning. Such innovation enjoyed public acclaim, and Sessa re-published the volume in 1578 and 1596 with minimal corrections. Of particular interest is the great authority given to Landino and Vellutello over Dante’s poem. Note, for example, how snippets of the Commedia are explained both by the ‘Argomento’ canto summary under the illustrations and by the double commentary which engulfs the terzine; this allows the commentators to guide the reader’s interpretation, reflecting medieval tradition whereby commentators largely assumed superiority over their subject texts. Considering Dante’s modern dominance within the Italian literary canon, such authority afforded to Landino and Vellutello intrigued me, with this hierarchical organisation – whereby the two commentators are, arguably, superior to the poet – what first drew me to the work. The combination of two commentaries, illustrations, and an extended introduction including a background on Dante’s Florence and his vocabulary, would have made this text an excellent guide to reading and understanding the poem. As a student of Italian myself, this insight into how Renaissance readers might have approached their study of Dante was what interested me most about the work.
Matthew Webb (Wadham College)
Lippmann, Friedrich. Zeichnungen von Sandro Botticelli zu Dante’s Goettlicher Komoedie: Nach den Originalen im K. Kupferstichkabinet zu Berlin (Berlin: G. Grote’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, 1887).
This facsimile of Botticelli’s original drawing from c. 1481–88 depicts the Terrace of Pride in canto X of Purgatorio. Botticelli’s drawings distinguished themselves from other fourteenth-century representations of Dante’s text in their presentation of a continuous narrative. Instead of focusing on a single incident in the canto, we are taken, like Dante, through the Terrace of Pride by Virgil, whose guiding arm indicates the chronology of the scene. First, we see Dante and Virgil emerging from a crevice in the bottom left. Then, having ascended onto the terrace itself, we see four separate scenes that move in a rightward direction. The first three of these, depicting Dante and Virgil gazing at marble engravings of biblical and pagan stories exemplifying humility, layer narratives within the main narrative of Dante and Virgil’s journey, mirroring the effect Dante creates in his text through ekphrastic descriptions of the engravings. In this way, Botticelli’s drawing captures the depth and complexity of Dante’s narrative, instead of presenting one static event. I find the astonishing level of detail intriguing, particularly the representation of marble engraving in the image, a virtuosic display of Botticelli’s own skill as a painter (and maybe also a sign of pride). The original was part of a wider collection of illustrations that were commissioned by the artist’s patron, Lorenzo di Pierfrancesco de’ Medici, which, when brought to sale in the late 19th century, were purchased by Friedrich Lippmann and placed in the Kupferstichkabinett in Berlin. This remarkably detailed set of facsimiles dates from around the time of the sale, an artefact in its own right.
Left: MS. 8o It.3 (1395 ). Right: Dante’s ‘Terrace of Pride’ (Purgatorio X), as illustrated by Botticelli
Olivia Ganderton (Pembroke College)
Lippmann, Friedrich. Zeichnungen von Sandro Botticelli zu Dante’s Goettlicher Komoedie: Nach den Originalen im K. Kupferstichkabinet zu Berlin (Berlin: G. Grote’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, 1887).
Dante’s Purgatory I, as illustrated by Bottiicelli
Botticelli’s late fifteenth-century drawing for Purgatorio I, often thought to have been commissioned by Lorenzo di Pierfrancesco de’ Medici, piqued my interest specifically due to the challenge posed to the artist to portray both this particular canto and introduce the viewer to a whole new cantica, that of Purgatory. The drawing shows Dante and Virgil entering the realm of Purgatory, where they meet its guardian, Cato (the figure furthest right), who then advises Virgil to wash Dante clean of the filth from his journey through Hell. Moving right to left, the following elements of the canto are illustrated: Cato halts the poets and asks them their business; Virgil plucks grass to cleanse Dante; Virgil wraps reeds around Dante’s waist; a ship-full of new souls arrives on the shores of Purgatory. These events occur one after the other, yet Botticelli decides to include each moment simultaneously in his drawing, giving a sense of unity and circularity to this stage of the afterlife, whilst choosing to give each stage equal status. This continuity is further emphasised by his inclusion of the ship-full of souls furthest to the right that will be described in the second canto of Purgatory, offering a conceptual connection between the composition of the image and movement of the narrative in the text.
Further Reading:
Antonov, Boris (2006). Russian Tsars. Saint Petersburg: Ivan Fiorodov Art Publishers.
Gombrich, E. H. (1979), ‘Giotto’s Portrait of Dante?’, The Burlington Magazine, 121.917: 471–483.
Parker, Deborah (2013), ‘Illuminating Botticelli’s Chart of Hell’, MLN, 128.1.
Ricci, Lucia Battaglia (2009), ‘Ai Margini del Testo: Considerazioni sulla Tradizione del “Dante illustrato”’, Italianistica, 38.2: 39–58.
Rosser, Geravse (2005), ‘Turning Tale into Vision: Time and the Image in the “Divina Commedia”’, RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics 48: 106–122.
The Japanese Photobook and the Sackler Library Display
Above: Ninagawa Mika. Tokyo from Utsurundesu series (since 2018). Models: AMIAYA. (Exhibition poster for Tokyo: Art and Photography. Ashmolean Museum, 2021) Copyright Ninagawa Mika, courtesy the artist and Tomio Koyama Gallery
Accompanying the Ashmolean Museum’s exhibition Tokyo: Art & Photography (29 July 2021 – 3 January 2022) a book display at the Sackler Library presents Japanese photobooks, books on Japanese photography and related exhibition catalogues. Over the coming weeks some of the Japanese photobooks held by the Sackler are on display (in the Ground Floor rotunda) for readers to take a closer look.
Works in the Bodleian Libraries’ collections (in particular, the Sackler Library and the Bodleian Japanese Library, or BJL) range from the 1965 book Why Mother Why, which features iconic photographer Hosoe Eikoh’s works, to multi-media artist Tokyo Rumando’s exhibition booklet from 2020. In her first European museum solo show, Tokyo Rumando presented her self-portrait photographs and films.
Takano Ryudai photobooks on display at the Ashmolean Museum. Credit: Dr Lena Fritsch
Since the end of the Second World War, Japan has dominated the international camera industry through companies such as Canon, Fujifilm, Nikon, Olympus, Sony or Pentax (previously Asahi). Supported by these companies, responsible for creating some of the best cameras, lenses and films in the world, photo galleries such as Fuji Salon or Canon Salon have hosted short-term exhibitions. Amateur photography clubs promote competitions, exhibitions and periodicals. Asahi Camera, founded in 1926 by the Asahi Newspaper Company, is the voice of the All-Japan Association of Photographic Societies (AJAPS, Zennihon Shashin Renmei) and is the country’s oldest photography magazine. It presents photographs, evaluations of equipment and exhibition reviews. Another popular magazine, Nippon Camera, has existed since 1951. The internet now provides access to images and texts, but until recently, photo magazines were a crucial source of information on photography, including works from overseas. Photography in Japan has developed into a web of camera companies, clubs, galleries, publishers, magazines and online platforms. More than an important industry, it also is a socio-cultural system based on countless photographers and camera fans, creating a vast number of high-quality images. This ‘photography world’ is a parallel system to the ‘art world’ in Japan, which has also produced important photographic works.
Range of Photobooks on display at the Tokyo exhibition. Credit: Dr Lena Fritsch
Moriyama Daidō’s photobooks (Record, edited by Mark Holburn; and Daido Moriyama: the World through my Eyes, edited by Filippo Maggia)
The photobook has become central to the development of Japanese photography, particularly since the post-war years. Considering Japan’s long tradition of making high-quality paper and books, as well as the lack of photography exhibition and storage space in densely populated Japanese cities, the popularity of the photobook is not surprising. Even today, for many photographers the photobook remains the ultimate format in which to present their works. Iconic photobooks by Fukase Masahisa, Araki Nobuyoshi or Kawada Kikuji continue to inspire younger artists worldwide. Over the last 30 years there has been a growing interest in Japanese photography, both within and outside of Japan, which has resulted in an increasing number of exhibitions. Japanese photobooks have also become sought-after internationally.
Tokyo has been a major motif in Japanese photography, ranging from Kimura Ihei’s post-war documentation to Moriyama Daidō’s dynamic snapshots of his Shinjuku neighbourhood, Araki Nobuyoshi’s diaristic Ginza photographs and Ninagawa Mika’s colourful images of her urban life. The number of photographs is endless, and Tokyo as a motif and shooting location is as varied as the city itself. While ‘truly copying’ the outside world (as the Japanese term for photography ‘shashin’ suggests), Japanese photography has developed from a ‘realist’ approach in the early post-war years to a free form of expression often intertwined with photographers’ lives and subjective experiences. Tokyo in photography has had many faces and no doubt it will continue to change, develop and re-imagine itself in the future. Perhaps the most engaging photographs of Tokyo, however, will continue to be linked to the photographers’ lives and inner visions.
Japanese Photobooks and photographs of Tokyo at the Ashmolean Museum. Credit: Dr Lena Fritsch
The Sackler Library’s book display seeks to provide a ‘taster’ of the diversity of Japanese photography, featuring well-known names, such as Araki and Moriyama, as well as younger female practitioners who are less well-known internationally, including Nagashima Yurie, Tonomura Hideka, and Tokyo Rumando. I hope that the display will inspire staff and students alike, reflecting both the quality of Japanese photography and the importance of the photobook as an artistic object in its own right. The work of many of these photographers has not yet been researched enough. The display runs during the course of Michaelmas term 2021, and beyond, and we invite you to take a closer look at the books!
Dr. Lena Fritsch Curator of Modern & Contemporary Art, Ashmolean Museum
Sackler books on show in the Ashmolean exhibition
The Sackler Library has lent three publications to the Ashmolean exhibition:
Kimura Ihei. Tokyo: Fall of 1945. Tokyo: Bunka-sha, 1946
Tsuzuki Kyoichi. Satellite of Love: Vanishing Beauty of Japanese ‘Love hotels’ . Tokyo: Asupekuto, 2001
Preparing the Display: My Personal Perspective as a Graduate Library Trainee
Sackler Library poster for the Japanese Photobook display
When I was asked to put together this display, I – of course – jumped at the opportunity. Since opening up to more readers (post-Covid), and reinstating its New Books Display, the Sackler Library is gradually returning to the bustle of its pre-Covid years. The Ashmolean’s advertising for the Tokyo exhibition is hard to miss: visitors to and passers-by the museum can see Ninagawa Mika’s bright photograph of two young women bowing their pink fringes towards each another, one of them adorned by a dazzling ‘Gucci’ clip (see above). I pass the Ashmolean poster daily, on my walk to work, and it never fails to catch my eye. Welcoming new and returning readers to the Sackler Library with a connected display seemed perfect timing. This post is a small insight into the process of setting up my first book display, and all I learned along the way.
Tokyo photobook display, Sackler Library
I set about gathering the list of Tokyo photobooks held by the Sackler Library, compiled by the Ashmolean exhibition’s co-curator, Dr Lena Fritsch. Once all the books were assembled, I quickly learned that Japanese photography does not comprise only colour images of vibrant scenes of Tokyo’s nightlife as represented in the exhibition’s poster. Leafing through For a New World to Come: Experiments in Japanese Art and Photography, I found countless greyscale shots. Without colour, the pictures are still remarkably expressive.
Spread from Oh! Shinjuku from For a new world to come: experiments in Japanese art and photography, Museum of Fine Arts, Houston
One of my preferred spreads from For a New World to Come is Shomei Tomatsu’s Oh! Shinjuku series (1969). These images show scenes of student protestors and railway passengers alongside moments from Tokyo nightlife. One of the most famous photos in the series, of a protestor clashing with the police, particularly stands out. Apparently, students had told Tomatsu about the protest (and the protestor’s) location, allowing the photographer to capture the moment. Through creating this display, I learned about the ‘are-bure-boke’ style: here, pictures are grainy or out-of-focus, just like Tomatsu’s shot. Its blurry look really captures the fast-moving pace of 1960s Tokyo: the student seems to glide through the air, showing you don’t always need bright colours to grasp the chaos of a place in time.
Looking at these images, you can see lots of parallels with other displayed books. We also have the works of Daidō Moriyama. In his introduction to Daido Moriyama (Tate, 2012) Simon Baker describes Moriyama as ‘one of Japan’s most important and influential photographers and photobook makers’, capturing the world since 1964. Inside, the book is undeniably varied – with a colour photography selection towards the end. Still, you cannot miss the familiar, blurred greyscale images throughout the book. In 1968, Moriyama joined a group called Provoke, and their eponymous magazine, where are-bure-boke was the trademark style. So, even by skimming photobooks, you can see a typical documentation style for 1960s Tokyo. As a staff member with no formal training in art history, there is something very satisfying about identifying themes and trends with a layman’s eye!
Cover of Daido Moriyama, edited by Simon Baker. 2012. Tate Publishing
When I was organising the display I came across more than 1960s photography. For example, Ishiuchi Miyako: Postwar Shadows (2015) includes works 1976-2007; her work is fascinating, ranging from shots of apartments to close-up images of human hands and skin. I decided to group photobooks covering a longer span of time together, for readers who want to delve deeper into the world of Japanese photography and see how it has evolved over time. (These groupings have now merged, as readers view and rearrange the books on display.)
The display also includes books normally housed in our offsite facility. Readers familiar with the Bodleian Libraries’ collections will know that we hold many, many books. Despite the plethora of libraries around Oxford, we cannot keep all of them in our onsite collections and a vast number are stored offsite. Books returned temporarily to onsite include, for example, other publications on Moriyama, as well as other artists’ photobooks.
Once all the books had arrived safely at the Sackler, I began putting up the display. With the exception of giving a helping hand during my work experience at a primary school, this was almost entirely new territory. Fortunately, the photobooks contain beautiful, powerful and intriguing images, which guided me in arranging the display. After a period of adjusting the table arrangements, the display was good to go.
Nobuyoshi Araki: Tokyo Still Life. 2001
When I was deciding where to place the books, there were two especially important points for me. Firstly, I knew I wanted to have a spread of books open: the display is, after all, about photography! Choosing which spread to have open was more difficult: I turned page after page, looking for the most (to me) compelling images. I eventually chose two photos from Nobuyoshi Araki: Tokyo Still Life, which show four young boys in conversation, and a striking woman sitting back and staring the camera down. To me, her gaze almost invites you in to look further at the books. (That said, our readers have enjoyed looking at the display since it went on show, and one of them subsequently changed the pages to display a sleeping cat. This is, of course, entirely welcome in the library. Our books are for readers to handle.)
Tokyo Rumando. The Story of S, 2020
Secondly, although all our books are available pick up and consider, I wanted Tokyo Rumando’s 2020 exhibition booklet to be particularly accessible. This is the most recent work on display, and by lesser-known female artist. I particularly wanted to encourage display browsers to engage with newer artists, to bring home how the world of Japanese photography world has evolved to present day. If you flick through her booklet, her work is a captivating story of female empowerment: between shots of women of all ages, clothes, and poses, she emerges as one of my new favourite creators. I hope everyone considering the display finds it as insightful as I did.
Shomei Tomatsu. Chewing Gum and Chocolate. Edited by Leo Rubinfien & John Junkerman, New York: Aperture, 2014
Naito Masatoshi: Another World Unveiled. Edited by Tetsurō Ishida & Satomi Fujimura. Tokyo: Tōkyō-to Shashin Bijutsukan, 2018
Sato Tokihiro: Presence or Absence. Tokyo Metropolitan Museum of Photography, 2014
Nagashima Yurie and a Pinch of Irony with a Hint of Love. Tokyo Museum of Photographic Art, 2017
Amanda Maddox and others. Ishiuchi Miyako: Postwar Shadows. Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty Museum, 2015
Yutaka Takanashi. Toshi-e / Towards the City. New York: Errata, 2010
The Founding and Development of Modern Photography in Japan. Tokyo Metropolitan Museum of Photography, 1995
Japan’s Modern Divide: the Photographs of Hiroshi Hamaya and Kansuke Yamamoto. Edited by Judith Keller and Amanda Maddox. Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty Museum, 2013
Sadly, for many of us, the last eighteen months have seen the cancellation, curtailment and delay of countless celebrations, including birthdays, holidays, anniversaries and achievements. At the very least, we’ve been forced to relocate those festivities online and connect with family and friends via laptops and phone screens in a kind of digital limbo.
Re-emerging into the real world from this pandemic-induced Purgatory, I recently returned to Oxford, a city that I’d previously called home for many years. My arrival overlapped with many of the restrictions of the last year and a half being (cautiously) rolled back. As the new Graduate Trainee at the Taylor Institution Library (known colloquially as the ‘Taylorian’), my first week saw the steady disappearance of one-way systems, sign-in slots and restricted access for readers to many of the library’s more intimate spaces.
Above: Taylor Institution Library, Aerial View (2008)
Like the Bodleian Libraries more broadly, many institutions and historical personages have also found their usual cycles of anniversaries and commemorations disrupted by lockdown measures and restrictions on large gatherings. Excitingly, the prospect of more freedom for staff and readers at the University of Oxford has coincided with another cause for celebration: the 700th anniversary of the death of Dante Alighieri (1265–1321), the great Italian poet and philosopher. As a result, the Taylor Institution Library, Weston Library and the Ashmolean Museum have prepared three exhibitions of works from among the libraries’ and museum’s many and varied holdings, which provide visions of, and insights into, the author’s most famous work, the Divine Comedy (Divina Commedia). Works from the Taylorian’s collections are included in the Ashmolean and Weston displays. The Taylorian exhibition, ‘Illustrating Dante’s Divine Comedy’, meanwhile, also draws upon the collections of the Sackler Library, Oxford’s principal research location for the study of visual culture. Alongside my regular duties at the library (with which I’m slowly familiarising myself), I’ve been fortunate enough to join Clare Hills-Nova (Librarian in Charge, Sackler Library, and Subject Librarian for Italian Literature and Language at the Taylorian) and Professor Gervase Rosser, curatorial lead on all three Oxford Dante exhibitions, in their preparations for the display of prints, manuscripts and illustrated books spanning the seven hundred years since Dante’s passing.
Above: Taylor Institution Library, University of Oxford (Architect C. R. Cockerell, 1841-45)
The photos provided here offer a window on the range of texts and images that were chosen for the Taylorian exhibition and the process that went into preparing them for public display. I came into that process after Clare and Gervase had agreed on the works to be included and their gathering from the Taylorian’s rare books and manuscript holdings and other library locations was complete. The exhibition handlist includes an introduction to the works on display as well as a list of works they considered for inclusion.
Together, Clare and I spent an afternoon preparing the exhibition space – among the already impressive holdings of the library’s Voltaire Room.
Above: Taylor Institution Library, Voltaire Room (ca. 2010)
A provisional placement of the exhibits according to the chronological layout agreed by Clare and Gervase gave us a sense of how the various prints, manuscripts and books would fit within the display cases.
Working with a number of old and rare editions – including some of the oldest books that I’ve had the opportunity to see first-hand during my time in Oxford – required careful handling and the use of foam rests and ‘snakes’ (long, cotton-wrapped metal ‘beads’ designed to hold open books). Clare has a background in conservation, so provided an experienced eye and guiding hand throughout the process.
Above: Preparing the display cases
After this initial test-run of the display cases, I was tasked with assisting in the preparation of a bibliography to provide visitors to the exhibition with a comprehensive list of texts on display, and those consulted during the curation process. This not only gave me an excellent opportunity to re-familiarise myself with the Bodleian Libraries’ SOLO (‘Search Oxford Libraries Online’) catalogue, but required some further detective work to collect the full details of some of the more obscure texts included in the exhibition.
Although I’m familiar with this kind of work from my time researching and writing Russian history, and searching for texts catalogued in various forms of transliterated Cyrillic, the preparations for this exhibition included consideration of works in Italian, French and German too. Exploiting the automatic citation tool provided on the SOLO also exposed the potential drawback of relying on technology alone. Each of these languages inevitably has its own bibliographic conventions for the formatting of references (authors, titles, publishing info, etc.), not all of which are captured by auto-generation of citations. Obviously, I still have plenty to learn on that front being based in one of Oxford’s key research centres for modern languages and linguistics!
Above: Testing the layout of the exhibits within the display case
The whole process also brought home how inconsistent and incomplete some of the catalogue descriptions are within the Bodleian Libraries’ older collections and more unique items. This is quite the mountain to climb for those librarians faced with such a vast (and ever expanding) number of books, journals, periodicals and other ephemera in every language under the sun.
One particular exhibit of note is shown below:
Above: A copy of Dante’s Divine Comedy dedicated to Empress Elizabeth Petrovna of Russia (daughter of Peter the Great). Published in Venice, Italy in 1757
It was wonderful to find such a striking connection between the history of Imperial Russia and Dante’s life and work!
The second set of photos below provides a view of the final layout for each display case. Supporting information to be included alongside the works was still being prepared at the time of taking, but a sense of the diversity of images and lasting influence of Dante’s work on artists, writers, print-makers and publishers across the world is evident already.
Students, faculty and staff from across the University are welcome to visit the Taylorian’s exhibition during library opening hours, from the beginning of Michaelmas term through December 2021. The parallel exhibitions marking Dante’s centenary celebrations are on display for a similar period: Ashmolean Museum (17 September 2021 – 9 January 2022) and Weston Library (8 September 2021 – 14 November 2021), which will give everyone interested in the life, history and influence of Dante the opportunity to explore the wider collections of the University.
Further Oxford Dante events, ranging from concerts to film screenings, to lectures and (of course!) at least one book launch celebrating the 700th anniversary are planned for autumn 2021.
Having now had an insight into the complexities involved in preparing, curating and displaying materials from our impressive Dante collections, the chance to come face-to-face with these exhibits sounds like Paradiso itself!
If you want to know more about Dante-related holdings in Oxford, please check out the Taylorian’s earlier blog posts in this regard (linked below):
International Women’s Day, a day dedicated to celebrating the achievements of women and challenging stereotypes, has been observed on 8March every year since its inception in 1911. The organisers of International Women’s Day describe it as “a time to reflect on progress made, to call for change and to celebrate acts of courage and determination by ordinary women, who have played an extraordinary role in the history of their countries and communities.”[1] The fight for women’s equality continues in the UK and around the world, and events like International Women’s Day show how important it is that women and girls are able to reach their full potential and contribute to all areas of our society. Each year, the organisers of International Women’s Day choose a theme as a banner under which everyone’s efforts can be channelled and unified. This year, the theme is I am Generation Equality: Realizing Women’s Rights. This theme aligns with UN Women’s new multigenerational campaign, Generation Equality: Realizing Women’s Rights for an Equal Future, which marks the 25th anniversary of the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action, the most progressive roadmap for the empowerment of women and girls, everywhere.[2]
“An equal world is an enabled world. Individually, we’re all responsible for our own thoughts and actions – all day, every day. We can actively choose to challenge stereotypes, fight bias, broaden perceptions, improve situations and celebrate women’s achievements. Collectively, each one of us can help create a gender equal world. Let’s all be #EachforEqual.”[3]
Image Credit: Logan Isbell, Unsplash
2020 also marks the 100th anniversary of a historic victory for women at the University of Oxford: in 1920 Mary-Anne Henley was the first to collect her degree in the Sheldonian Theatre. To mark this centenary and celebrate the contribution of women to Oxford, the University is launching Women Making History: 100 Years of Oxford degrees for women:
“The centenary provides an opportunity to take stock of our progress in promoting women’s education and advancing gender equality and diversity.”
As the website also notes:
“Women Making History will shine a spotlight on the diverse women who have contributed to the University of Oxford, as well as the women who are shaping its future today. In the coming months, we will explore stories of Oxford women as scholars, students, researchers, academics, clinicians, technicians, librarians, archivists, activists, artists and much more. If you have a story about an Oxford woman that you think should be told, please join the conversation by using the hashtag #womenatoxford.”[4]
To celebrate International Women’s Day — and to mark the 100th anniversary of Oxford degrees for Women — members of the Sackler Reader Services team compiled a Virtual Book Display. (Sadly, visibility of the physical book display was curtailed by the Covid-19 lockdown.) At the end of this blog post, you will find a list of links to various e-publications, available via SOLO, which focus on women’s accomplishments as they relate to Archaeology, Art, Architecture, Classics and Egyptology – some of the areas of collecting focus at the Sackler Library.
It is wrong to assume that amongst the most celebrated figures in Classics, hardly any women feature. Of course, there is the Greek poet Sappho. We have chosen to display Nancy Rabinowitz and Lisa Auanger’s Among Women, which focuses on Sappho’s poetic creativity and erotic themes. We can never discuss key female figures in Classics without mentioning Hypatia of Alexandria, as discussed by Dora Russell. The poems of Sulpicia are a rarity. In comparison with works by other Roman women, Sulpicia’s work has survived intact, rather than existing in fragments. Her six poems appear in the Augustan poet Tibullus’ corpus of poetry, a translation of which appears in our display. For those interested in reception theory, James Donaldson’s Woman considers the position of women in Classical and Early Christian societies through the lens of a male academic in Edwardian Britain.
Pieere Olivier Joseph Coomans, Sappho at Mitylene, 1876 (Image: Wikimedia Commons)
“We can also see the contributions of women in Ancient Egypt where, as many may be aware, it was not unknown for women to hold positions of power. Mary Hamer’s Signs of Cleopatra and Dorothea Arnold’s Royal Women of Amarna discuss two of perhaps the most well-known female figureheads of Egypt: Cleopatra and Nefertiti. However, another noteworthy addition is the fifth Pharaoh to rule Egypt during the Eighteenth Dynasty, as discussed in Catherine Roehrig et al.’s Hatshepsut: From Queen to Pharoah. Hatshepsut brought about religious infrastructure and trade reform during her 21-year reign, but all records relating to her activities were systematically destroyed by her successor, Thutmose III.
Artemisia Gentileschi, Judith Beheading Holofernes, by Artemisia Gentileschi (Naples, Museo di Capodimonte), 1612-13 (Image: Wikimedia Commons)
It is a pleasure when the female story is celebrated and represented well, as many in the art world have been striving for since gender inequality became part of their consciousness, and since feminist art historians such as Linda Nochlin (“Why there have been no great women artists”, 1971) and Griselda Pollock drew attention to the issue. Art movements and artists have put visions into visuals, alongside providing the artwork to promote diversity and alternate views to the much discussed male gaze. Fortunately, for art, there have been many female artists such as Artemisia Gentileschi (as discussed in Keith Christiansen’s Orazio and Artemisia Gentileschi or at the now-postponed National Gallery exhibition, Artemisia, in London), who were as successful as their male counterparts during their lifetimes. This allows us to witness alternative art histories and celebrate historical women artists who worked side-by-side with male artists. We can also fight for them to be recognised in the archives and great libraries, worldwide, so that we are aware of women who came before us as well as those who are alive today, contributing to the modern art world as we know it — for example, Jenny Saville, whose first solo show in a UK public institution was held at Modern Art Oxford. For those interested in further exploring the work of women artists during lockdown, Modern Art Oxford’s online exhibition archive is showcasing exhibitions by three artists: Invisible Strategiesby Lubaina Himid, Wandererby Kiki Smith, and Tools For Life by Johanna Unzueta.
The discussion of women’s contribution to the field of architecture is a more is a more complicated one. Compared with the strides taken in the art world, architecture is much further behind in its recognition of its female figures. There are few female architects within the pages of the architectural history books that are celebrated in the same way as their male counterparts, which begs the question: what historical examples do we have, if any, of women in the architectural world? Women’s presence in architecture was often suppressed, as was the case with Annie Albers, who was unable to study architecture at the Bauhaus (whose proponents considered that architecture was a men-only professions) and so turned to weaving instead. Her work is noted for its architectural qualities and the innovation she brought to weaving techniques, showing how her interest in architecture and space could not be erased. (See, for example, her 2018-2019 exhibition at Tate Modern.)
Due to the past elusiveness of female figures in architecture, it is therefore difficult to celebrate qualities of architectural practice which are acknowledged as “feminine”. Even though a variety of books have been written on the intersection between feminism and architecture, including key works which form much of the basis of gendered architectural theory such as Beatriz Colomina’s Sexuality and Space, women still struggle to identify feminist architecture, what it is, and how it should be practised. Women have often struggled to gain recognition in architecture, leading to the controversial problem of their preferring not to identify as “female architects” or “women architects”. This is particularly true of high achieving female architects: they do not want their title of architect to be gendered. This is discussed in Francesca Hughes’ The Architect: Reconstructing Her Practice, one of the few monographs which celebrates the work of women architects. It is to be understood that women architects believed that if they left out any reference to their gender, then they would be seen and treated as equals. However, as well meaning as this appears, this provides leverage for the erasure of the narrative of women and the dismissal of the problems and experiences women may have experienced due to gender discrimination within the profession.
Book cover: Maggie Toy, ed. The Architect: Women in Contemporary Architecture (2001)
This can also lead to questions of privilege held by the contributors for them to not have experienced any discrimination; and to the belief that other narratives do not exist or that gender is not a problem. The publication The Architect: Women in Contemporary Architecture, edited by Maggie Toy, is a key source on women in architecture, but the women in question objected to such potential titles for the book as “The Female Architect”. The best they could do to give a nod towards the representation of women was the subtle adaptation of the Venus sign in the title on the book’s cover.
Venus symbol (Image: Wikimedia Commons)
Despite the issues raised, it is important to recognise the accomplishments of the feminist movement in the fields collected by the Sackler Library. We hope that the reading list at the end of this post will provide a small insight into what has already been achieved.
If you would like to learn more about women’s history and gender studies in February and March 2020 the Bodleian Libraries provided trial access to a wide range of related informational databases, arranged as part of Changing the Narrative: Championing Inclusive Collection Development, a project led by Helen Worrell, Bodleian Libraries’ Anthropology & Archaeology Subject Librarian. The following databases were available during the trials and, for one of them, we have temporary extended access. A decision on whether to purchase any of these databases (based on reader feedback) is in the works.
We hope you will enjoy browsing this small selection of our collections, and we hope you will spend some time remembering Women at Oxford 1920-2020.
Through the writings of women activists, their personal letters and diaries, and the proceedings of conferences at which pivotal decisions were made, this collection lets you see how women’s social movements shaped much of the events and attitudes that have defined modern life. This digital archive includes 150,000 pages of conference proceedings, reports of international women’s organizations, publications and web pages of women’s non-governmental organizations, and letters, diaries, and memoirs of women active internationally since the mid-nineteenth century. It also includes photographs and videos of major events and activists in the history of women’s international social movements.
Women’s Magazine Archive 1 provides access to the complete archives of the foremost titles of this type, including Good Housekeeping and Ladies’ Home Journal, which serve as canonical records of evolving assumptions about gender roles and cultural mores. Other titles here focus on narrower topics but deliver valuable source content for specific research areas. Parents, for example, is of particular relevance for research in the fields of children’s education, psychology, and health, as well as reflecting broader social historical trends. Women’s Magazine Archive 2 features several of the most prominent, high-circulating, and long-running publications in this area, such as Woman’s Day and Town & Country. Collection 2 also, however, complements the first collection by including some titles focusing on more specific audiences and themes. Cosmopolitan and Seventeen, for example, are oriented towards a younger readership, while black women’s interests are represented by Essence. Women’s International Network News differs in being a more political, activist title, with an international dimension. Topics covered these collections include family life, home economics, health, careers, fashion, culture, and many more; this material serves multiple research areas, from gender studies, social history, and the arts, through to education, politics, and marketing/media history.
Women’s Studies Archive
The Women’s Studies Archive: Issues and Identities will focus on the social, political, and professional achievements of women throughout the nineteenth and twentieth century. Along with providing a closer look at some of the pioneers of women’s movements, this collection offers scholars a deep dive into the issues that have affected women and the many contributions they have made to society.
International Women’s Day – Virtual Book Display: a selection of e-books at Oxford
Aceves Sepúlveda, G., 2019. Women made visible: feminist art and media in post-1968 Mexico City.
We welcome suggestions for future blog contributions from our readers. Please contact Clare Hills-Nova (clare.hills-nova@bodleian.ox.ac.uk) and Chantal van den Berg (chantal.vandenberg@bodleian.ox.ac.uk) if you would like propose a topic.
February marks LGBT+ History Month in the UK, which aims to educate people about and increase visibility of the accomplishments of LGBT+ identifying people, and the contributions they have made and continue to make to society. Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer and asexual people, as well as people of other gender, sexual and romantic minority groups, have been present in the arts, the sciences and daily life from ancient times to the modern day. The Sackler Library has chosen to celebrate the rich history and diversity of the LGBT+ community by means of a book display highlighting the contribution of LGBT+ people to the areas of study within the remit of the Sackler Library.
The display in place on the Ground Floor of the Sackler Library Image. Credit: Erin McNulty
In terms of Classical literature, our display highlights the work of Sappho, e.g. in Rayor and Lardinois’ Sappho: a new translation of the complete works (2014). Sappho was a prolific lyric poet from the Archaic Greek era[1]. Her poetry was well-known and greatly admired through much of antiquity, and she was among the canon of nine lyric poets most highly esteemed by scholars of Hellenistic Alexandria. She is also the subject of some scholarly debate, but it is generally thought amongst modern scholars that her work portrays evidence of love and desire between women[2]. Indeed, the modern use of the word ‘lesbian’ is derived from the name of her home island of Lesbos.
We can also see the contributions of LGBT+ people in the field of Egyptology, namely through Amelia Edwards’ A Thousand Miles up the Nile, a best-selling travelogue published in 1877. Edwards, born in 1831, was an English novelist, journal-writer, and traveller, and contributed greatly to Egyptological Studies, co-founding the Egypt Exploration Fund in 1882[4]. She was also the founder of the Edwards Chair of Egyptology at University College London. Edwards died in 1892 from influenza, and was buried alongside her partner, Ellen Drew Braysher. In 2016, her grave in Bristol was designated as Grade II listed by Historic England, and is celebrated as a landmark of English LGBT+ history[5].
Joseph Bonomi. Design for a carpet at Bowood House
The cover, an illustration, and author’s signature from an 1877 edition of Edwards’ A Thousand Miles up the Nile (Sackler Library, Special Collections)
To view Special Collections materials, please enquire at the Sackler Issue Desk
Image(s) Credit: Erin McNulty
We have also highlighted the relevance of LGBT+ studies to the study of architecture by including Betsky’s Queer space: architecture and same-sex desire (1997). This work discusses how same-sex desire is creating an entirely new design process. Vincent’s LGBT people and the UK cultural sector: the response of libraries, museums, archives and heritage since 1950 (2014) also deals with LGBT+ influences in the library and heritage sector specifically.
Image Credit: Erin McNulty
Works on art also form a substantial part of the Sackler’s collections. Both of these disciplines benefit greatly from the contributions of the LGBT+ community. Davis’ Gay and lesbian studies in art history (1994) gives an overview of this. We have also chosen to showcase art books dealing with LGBTQ+ themes from earlier periods, such as Mills’ Seeing sodomy in the Middle Ages (2015), to the more modern, e.g. David Wojnarowicz: history keeps me awake at night and Robert Mapplethorpe: the Archive.
A library’s collections can tell the story of a community, such as the LGBT+ community, and it changes as new works are acquired. How the Sackler, as well as many other libraries across the Bodleian, tells these stories will be reviewed by the upcoming project Changing the Narrative: Championing Inclusive Collection Development. This project, led by Helen Worrell, “will champion diversifying our collection development across the Social Sciences and Humanities Libraries, with the aim of enhancing collections in areas such as LGBTIQ+ Studies, Disability Studies, Indigenous Studies, Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (BAME) Studies and the intersections between these identities. This will enable us to think critically about the collections we currently hold so that we are aware of the gaps and the narrative these collections tell.”[5] Keep an eye out on the Sackler blog for upcoming posts regarding this project, or head to the LibGuide for more information.
Our book display also ties in to the theme of 2020’s LGBT+ History Month, launched at the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford: Poetry, Prose and Plays. We showcase works by all four featured authors: Dawn Langley Simmons’ Man into woman: a transsexual autobiography (1970), E. M. Forster’s Collected short stories (1947), Lorraine Hansberry’s A raisin in the sun (2011), and William Shakespeare’s Sonnets (1945 edition). We have also featured the work of ancient authors, such as Plutarch, Virgil, and Petronius, who are now thought by some scholars to have been LGBT+[6]. You can visit the LBGT+ History Month website for more information and resources.
An image of the display, showing Shakespeare’s Sonnet 20, which is thought to have been written about a man. Image Credit: Erin McNulty
We hope you enjoy browsing the books we have on offer on our display. However, these are only a small sample of the resources the Sackler, and the University of Oxford as a whole, has to offer for anyone interested in LGBT+ studies. For example, TORCH’s Queer Studies Network meets weekly for lectures, reading groups, seminars, workshops and events. The Bodleian Libraries are also currently trialling several informational databases, accessible through SOLO, e.g.:
Archives of Sexuality and Gender (Gale Cengage)
This resource spans the sixteenth to twentieth centuries and is the largest digital collection of historical primary source publications relating to the history and study of sex, sexuality, and gender research and gender studies research. Documentation covering disciplines such as social, political, health, and legal issues impacting LGBT communities around the world is included, as well as rare and unique books on sex and sexuality.
LGBT Magazine Archive (Proquest LLC)
Includes the archives of 26 leading but previously hard-to-find magazines, including many of the longest-running, most influential publications of this genre. For example, the complete backfile of the US publication, The Advocate, one of the very few LGBT titles to pre-date the 1969 Stonewall riots, is made available digitally for the first time. Other titles include the UK’s Gay News and its successor publication Gay Times.
LGBT Life Full Text (EBSCO)
Provides scholarly and popular LGBT+ publications in full text, plus historically important primary sources, including monographs, magazines and newspapers. It also includes a specialised LGBT+ thesaurus containing thousands of terms, 140+ full-text journals, approaching 160 full-text books and reference materials, 260+ abstracted and indexed journals and more than 350+ abstracted and indexed books and reference works.
Also, don’t miss other LGBT+ projects at the University of Oxford! For example, the Pitt Rivers Museum’s project, Beyond the Binary, due to launch this month, will work with local, national and international partners to explore the global diversity of sexual and gender identities. The project will challenge historical interpretations of the museum’s collections so that all visitors can understand humanity better. It will also include a community-focused acquisition programme for LGBT+ cultural and historical artefacts. Objects will be collected from British communities and across the globe that highlight traditions of gender non-conformity, bringing British LGBT+ heritage into conversation with global LGBT+ material culture.
We hope that you will join us in celebration of LGBT+ History Month, and that you have a fantastic February!
Erin McNulty,
Graduate Library Trainee
References
[1] Campbell, D. A. (ed.) (1982). Greek Lyric 1: Sappho and Alcaeus (Loeb Classical Library No. 142). Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass
[2]Rayor, Diane; Lardinois, André (2014). Sappho: A New Translation of the Complete Works. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[3] Rees, Joan (1998). Amelia Edwards: Traveller, Novelist and Egyptologist. London: Rubicon Press.
[4] Queer history’ landmarks celebrated by Historic England”. BBC News. 23 September 2016. Retrieved 24 September 2016.
[6] Claude J. Summers, ed., The Gay and Lesbian Literary Heritage: A Reader’s Companion to the Writers and Their Works, from Antiquity to the Present (New York: Henry Holt, 1995)
Book Display Bibliography
Benson, M., 1901. The soul of a cat, and other stories. London.
Betsky, A., 1997. Queer space: architecture and same-sex desire, New York.
Boehringer, S., 2007. L’homosexualité féminine dans l’antiquité grecque et romaine, Paris.
Breslin, D., Kiehl, D., & Wojnarowicz, D. (2018). David Wojnarowicz : History Keeps Me Awake at Night.
Cook, M. & Oram, A., 2017. Prejudice & pride: celebrating LGBTQ heritage, Warrington.
Davidson, J. N., 2007. The Greeks and Greek love: a radical reappraisal of homosexuality in ancient Greece, London
Davis, W., 1994. Gay and lesbian studies in art history, New York.
Dedichen, H. & Butin, H., 2013. Warhol’s queens. Ostfildern.
Dover, K. J., 1978. Greek homosexuality, London.
DuBois, P., 2015. Sappho. London; New York.
Edwards, A.B., 1982. A thousand miles up the Nile. London.
Forster, E.M., 1947. Collected short stories of E.M. Forster. London.
Hansberry, L., 2011. A raisin in the sun. London.
Horace & Bennett, Charles E, 1960. The Odes and Epodes. London.
Mapplethorpe, R., Martineau, P., & Salvesen, B., 2016. Robert Mapplethorpe: the photographs, Los Angeles.
Mapplethorpe, R., Terpak, F., Brunnick, M., Smith, P., & Weinberg, J., 2016. Robert Mapplethorpe: the archive, Los Angeles.
Meyer, R., 2003. Outlaw representation: censorship & homosexuality in twentieth-century American art, Boston.
Mills, R., 2015. Seeing sodomy in the Middle Ages, Chicago.
Parkinson, R. B., 2013. A little gay history: desire and diversity across the world, London.
Plutarch, Romm, James S & Mensch, Pamela, 2012. Plutarch: lives that made Greek history. Indianapolis.
Sappho, Rayor, Diane J. & Lardinois, A. P. M. H., 2014. Sappho: a new translation of the complete works. Cambridge.
Rorato, L., 2014. Caravaggio in film and literature: popular culture’s appropriation of a baroque genius, London.
Rothbauer, P. Locating the library as place among lesbian, gay, bisexual, and queer patrons, in eds. Buschman, J., & Leckie, G. J., 2007. The library as place: history, community, and culture, Westport; London.
Shakespeare, W. & Bullen, A.H., 1945. The sonnets of William Shakespeare. Oxford.
Simmons, D.L., 1970. Man into woman: a transsexual autobiography. London.
Spike, J. T., Brown, D. A., Joannides, P., De Groft, A. H., Rogers, M., & Bisogniero, C., 2015. Leonardo da Vinci and the idea of beauty, Williamsburg, Virginia.
Vicinus, M., 2004. Intimate friends: women who loved women, 1778-1928. Chicago.
Vincent, J., 2014. LGBT people and the UK cultural sector: the response of libraries, museums, archives and heritage since 1950. Farnham.
Virgil, Dryden, John & Keener, Frederick M., 1997. Virgil’s Aeneid. London.
Warhol, A., Feldman, F., & Defendi, C., 2003. Andy Warhol prints: a catalogue raisonné: 1962-1987, New York.
Wasserman, N., 2016. Akkadian love literature of the third and second millennium BCE. Weisbaden.
Weinberg, J., 1993. Speaking for vice: homosexuality in the art of Charles Demuth, Marsden Hartley, and the first American avant-garde, New Haven; London.
Weinberg, J., 2004. Male desire: the homoerotic in American art, New York.
Williams, C. A., 1999. Roman homosexuality: ideologies of masculinity in classical antiquity, New York; Oxford.
Williamson, M., 1995. Sappho’s immortal daughters. Cambridge, Mass.; London
Wojnarowicz, D., 2018. The waterfront journals. London
We welcome suggestions for future blog contributions from our readers. Please contact Clare Hills-Nova (clare.hills-nova@bodleian.ox.ac.uk) and Chantal van den Berg (chantal.vandenberg@bodleian.ox.ac.uk) if you would like propose a topic.