December 2018 – new reports, books and journal articles

Independent report
Sir Ron Kerr review: empowering NHS leaders to lead
This review was led by Sir Ron Kerr and explored 3 challenges faced by executive leaders across the NHS:

  • expectations and support available for leaders
  • alignment of performance expectations at the organisational and system level
  • level of administrative burden placed upon executive leaders

The review makes a number of recommendations to address these challenges.
Published 28 November 2018
National Health Executive commentary here
Adam Smith Institute commentary here 

King IV for Health and Social Care
Dr John Bullivant, Chairman, Good Governance Institute
Developed with input from NHS Trust and Foundation Trust Board
members as part of the 2018 national development programme with
NHS Improvement.
November 2018
Excerpt “NHSI recommends In-depth, regular and externally facilitated developmental reviews of leadership and governance as good practice across all industries. Rather than assessing current performance, these reviews should identify the areas of leadership and governance of organisations that would benefit from further targeted development work to secure and sustain future performance. The external input is vital to safeguard against the optimism bias and group think to which even the best organisations may be  susceptible. They therefore encourage all providers to carry out externally facilitated, developmental reviews of their leadership and governance using the well-led framework every three to five years, according to their circumstances.”

Leadership in integrated care systems (ICSs)
Report prepared for the NHS Leadership Academy
Future of care No 9 – November 2018
Excerpt “This Future of Care paper, aimed at chief executives, directors and senior managers from the NHS, local authorities, housing organisations and voluntary and community sector, is based on findings from interviews with systems leaders and a review of the literature. The NHS Leadership Academy commissioned SCIE to undertake this research to further expand the understanding of systems leadership and leadership of integrated care systems. The research will inform the Leadership Academy’s long-term plans for supporting leaders in integrated care systems. ”

Excerpt “Key messages

  • NHS moves to end ‘fractured’ care system (NHS England, 2017) says, Integrated care systems (ICSs) are a critical part of the biggest national move to integrating care of any major western country.
  • With no basis in law, ICSs are entirely dependent on a collaborative approach to leadership and a willingness on the part of the organisations involved to work together.
  • Leadership in ICSs is very much a form of systems leadership, but with new and unique challenges, such as the need to exert influence across an even larger range of organisations and co-produce services with people who use them.
  • Effective systems leadership relies on a composite set of capabilities and behaviours, which can be grouped under the following four domains (NHS Leadership Academy Systems Leadership Framework):
    • innovation and improvement
    • relationships and connectivity
    • individual effectiveness
    • learning and capacity-building.
  • Leaders in ICSs need to be skilled at:
    • identifying and scaling innovation (e.g. from pilots)
    • having a strong focus on outcomes and population health
    • building strong relationships with other leaders, and often working with them informally to develop joint priorities and plans
    • establishing governance structures which drive faster change, often going where the commitment and energy is strongest
    • setting the overall outcomes and expectations on behaviours, but handing day-to-day decision-making to others
    • supporting the development of multidisciplinary teams (MDTs)
    • designing and facilitating whole-systems events and workshops to build consensus and deliver change
    • understanding and leading cultural change
    • building system-wide learning and evaluation frameworks
    • fostering a learning culture across the whole system.
  • Leaders told us that they would welcome support in the following areas:
    • skilled external facilitation, to help deliver complex programmes
    • the creation of ‘safe spaces’ for leaders to meet with peers and share problems and solutions
    • more opportunities to learn from other professions and sectors
    • systems leadership development for middle managers across the system
    • masterclasses on:
      • co-production theory and practice
      • finance and risk-sharing
      • scaling innovation
      • understanding local government and social care
      • large-scale and large-group facilitation
      • working and influencing across multiple layers of governance.

Leadership within the NHS (Speech )
Matt Hancock speaks at the Leaders in Healthcare conference about leadership culture change in the NHS and the importance of ensuring we have the right leaders in place with the correct support.
15th November 2018

Matt Hancock speech to The King’s Fund, 28 November 2018

Independent report by the Faculty of Medical Leadership and Management , setting out the barriers and enablers for clinicians moving into senior leadership roles within the NHS.
15th November 2018
Commentary by GPOnline here 

Letting Local Systems Lead: How the NHS Long Term Plan can deliver a Sustainable NHS
published by NHS Confederation, 16th November 2018
Excerpt : “When asked what would make a difference, local leaders identified better local partnership working, improved engagement with staff, patients and communities, more effective local governance and a more supportive oversight regime” Based on the findings, and our own analysis of the challenges facing the service, the NHS Confederation is calling for the long-term plan to: Make support for effective local leadership and relationships a priority.

The health care workforce in England: make or break?
The King’s Fund, 15 November 2018
Excerpt “This briefing will be followed in the coming weeks by a more in-depth report that
explores five key levers available nationally and locally that could help ameliorate the
workforce crisis. These levers are: training; international recruitment; better employment
practice; pay and conditions; and maximising the potential of staff through better use
of existing skills, enhancing those skills and redesigning roles.”

Brexit and the Health and Social Care Workforce in the UK 
Prepared for the Cavendish Coalition for the project, National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR)
November 6th 2018
See also https://www.peoplemanagement.co.uk/news/articles/hospitals-spending-thousands-to-secure-settled-status 

Podcasts : Michael Hyatt’s podcasts [https://michaelhyatt.com/?s=leadership]

How Women Manage the Gendered Norms of Leadership
Harvard Business Review, November 28th 2018

NHS England lift legal directions for quality of leadership at three clinical commissioning groups

12th November 2018
Excerpt: “Crawley, East Surrey and Horsham and Mid Sussex CCGs have been praised by NHS England for the significant improvements that have been made to the governance, capability and capacity of the organisations.”

Seven Learning And Development Trends To Adopt In 2019
Forbes, Sep 24, 2018
1. C-suite and HR work together better to align goals.
2. Develop competencies for future organizational goals.
3. Emphasize communication skills.
4. Increase the gamification of training.
5. View training as an employee benefit and bait for talent acquisition.
6. Weigh learner-centric against content-oriented training.
7. Digital and mobile content and delivery are more critical than ever.

Our Strategic Intent 2018/19 – 2022/23 
London Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Mentions workforce issues, inclusion and leadership
“Inclusion – Organisations that are committed to embedding ‘difference’ demonstrate the ability to make better decisions and deliver better performance and better outcomes – in our case for our patients. For us, this not only means having a more diverse organisation that better reflects the population we serve, but also a more inclusive and welcoming organisation for the different professional groups that will make up vital parts of the response that we provide to our patients”

NHS Trust announced top for equality, diversity and inclusion
12th November 2018
Excerpt: “The National Centre for Diversity recently carried out a survey of 41 NHS organisations at board level. Our Trust [Coventry and Warwickshire Partnership NHS Trust] were found to be top for understanding and delivering on equality, diversity and inclusion in their organisation. The National Centre for Diversity will also be producing a comprehensive report to support the judgement. ”

New books

Transformational Leadership for the Helping Professions: Engaging Head, Heart, and Soul
Oxford University Press 
 Published: 22 November 2018

Cover for Transformational Leadership for the Helping Professions

Leadership with impact
Preparing Health and Human Service Practitioners in the Age of Innovation and Diversity
Oxford University Press, Published: 31 January 2019 (Estimated)

Cover for Leadership with Impact

  • Features 15 interviews with current health and human service leaders
  • Includes case studies and examples of leadership applications in the health and human services

Discovering Leadership: Designing Your Success
March 2019 | 504 pages | SAGE Publications, Inc

Discovering Leadership

Excerpt from Sage website ” Organized around five major design challenges, each challenge is explored in a stand-alone module. Students begin the leadership journey with themselves, understanding their own strengths, styles, and skills. The text moves on to relationships, exploring how leadership is a process that involves values, decision-making, motivation, and power. A module on others’ success unpacks the most effective practices of leadership and management, this is followed by a module on leading culture, teams, and community, before concluding with a section on how leaders can create lasting, positive change.”

journal articles

Healthcare leadership with political astuteness (HeLPA): a qualitative study of how service leaders understand and mediate the informal ‘power and politics’ of major health system change
Forthcoming research: EXCERPT ” The research will produce evidence about the relatively under-researched contribution that political skill and astuteness makes in the implementation of strategic health system change. It intends to offer new understanding of these skills and capabilities that takes greater account of the wider social, cultural organisational landscape, and offers tangible lessons and case examples for service leaders. The study will inform future learning materials and processes, and create spaces for future leaders to reflect upon their political astuteness in a constructive and development way.”

Organizational uptake of NICE guidance in promoting employees’ psychological health
A Weinberg, J H Hudson, A Pearson, S B Chowdhury
Occupational Medicine 2018 November 7
Excerpt “The role of sector and size of organization is relevant to uptake of some features of NICE guidance, although organizational leadership is important where raised awareness and implementation are concerned.”
A total of 163 organizations participated in a survey of UK-based private, public and third sector organizations employing an accumulated minimum of 322 033 workers.

Rising to the challenge: Epilepsy specialist nurses as leaders of service improvements and change (SENsE study)
Agnes Higgins, Carmel Downes, Jarleth Varley, Colin P Doherty, Cecily Begley, Naomi Elliott
Seizure,  2018 Nov 1; 63:40-47
Excerpt: “RESULTS: Five key areas in which ESNs demonstrated leading on the change agenda were identified. These included: Initiating new clinical practice developments; Building capability within the multidisciplinary team; Developing education programmes and resources for people with epilepsy, family and the public; Exerting influence through membership of committees and lobbying; and Advancing the ESN role.”

 Unnecessary Frills: Communality as a Nice (But Expendable) Trait in Leaders
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01866/full
Andrea C Vial, Jaime L Napier
Frontiers in Psychology 2018, 9: 1866
Excerpt: “We assessed men’s and women’s idea of a great leader with a focus on gendered attributes in two studies using different methodologies. In Study 1, we employed a novel paradigm in which participants were asked to design their “ideal leader” to examine the potential trade-off between leadership characteristics that were more stereotypically masculine (i.e., agency) and feminine (i.e., communality). Results showed that communality was valued in leaders only after meeting the more stereotypically masculine requirements of the role (i.e., competence and assertiveness), and that men in particular preferred leaders who were more competent (vs. communal), whereas women desired leaders who kept negative stereotypically masculine traits in check (e.g., arrogance). In Study 2, we conducted an experiment to examine men’s and women’s beliefs about the traits that would be important to help them personally succeed in a randomly assigned leader (vs. assistant) role, allowing us to draw a causal link between roles and trait importance. We found that both men and women viewed agentic traits as more important than communal traits to be a successful leader. Together, both studies make a valuable contribution to the social psychological literature on gender stereotyping and bias against female leaders and may illuminate the continued scarcity of women at the very top of organizations, broadly construed.”

How to Make or Break Implicit Bias Instruction: Implications for Curriculum Development
Cristina M Gonzalez, Ramya J Garba, Alyssa Liguori, Paul R Marantz, M Diane McKee, Monica L Lypson
Academic Medicine: Journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges 2018, 93
Excerpt ” Buy-in from institutional leadership is essential for successful implementation of implicit bias teaching, and medical educators need to consider formalized longitudinal curricula addressing the recognition and management of implicit biases.”

 Developing your leadership skills
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17453054.2018.1483190
David Bryson
Journal of Visual Communication in Medicine 2018 October 17, : 1-2

Impact of educational leadership and interprofessional learning on vascular access training
Anna Hulse, Jill Cochrane
British Journal of Nursing: BJN 2018 October 18, 27 (19): S4-S18

Respectful leadership: Reducing performance challenges posed by leader role incongruence and gender dissimilarity
Hum Relat. 2018 Dec;71(12):1590-1610
van Gils S et al

Perceived value of leadership experiences in a postgraduate year 2 ambulatory care pharmacy residency
Am J Health Syst Pharm. 2018 Dec 1;75(23 Supplement 4):S101-S107
Smith LC et al

Health-promoting leadership: A qualitative study from experienced nurses’ perspective
J Clin Nurs. 2018 Dec;27(23-24):4290-4301
Furunes T, Kaltveit A and  Akerjordet K

Advances in Chronic Kidney Disease
Special issue on leadership in Nephrology – November 2018, Vol 25, issue 6 
Edited by Rebecca J. Schmidt

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *